BULLETIN
February 2000 Volume LXXVI Number 5
EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE MEETING Executive Committee Authority
and Responsibility -
The Executive Committee was reminded of its authority under Article
VII of the MHSAA Constitution and specifically its responsibility
to consider each application for waiver of an eligibility requirement
on its individual merits, determining if the regulation serves
the purpose for which it was intended in each case or if the regulation
works an undue hardship on any student who is the subject of a
request for waiver. (These underlying criteria may not be restated
for every subject of these minutes.)
The
Executive Committee was reminded that it was the responsibility
of each member school involved to provide sufficient factual information
about the specific request for the Executive Committee to reach
a decision without further investigation. If information is incomplete,
contradictory or otherwise unclear or has been received too late
to be studied completely, the Executive Committee may deny the
request for waiver or delay action. Such requests may be resubmitted
to the Executive Committee with additional information at a subsequent
meeting or appealed to the full Representative Council.
A determination of undue hardship
is a matter addressed to the discretion of the Executive Committee
within the educational philosophy and secondary role of voluntary
extracurricular competitive athletics in the academic environment.
The Executive Committee was cautioned to avoid making exceptions
that would create precedent that effectively changes a rule without
Representative Council action or local board of education adoption,
which would exceed Executive Committee authority.
Students for whom waiver of
a particular regulation is granted must be eligible in all respects
under all other sections and interpretations of the regulations
prior to their participation.
Consistent
with rulings of the Attorney General and Michigan Supreme Court,
schools are not bound by the decisions of the Executive Committee,
but the Association may limit participation in the post-season
tournaments it sponsors to those schools which apply rules and
penalties as promulgated by the MHSAA and adopted by each member
school's board of education, and the MHSAA exercises no independent
authority over schools or students.
Capac High School (Regulation
I, Section 9[B]) -
Request to waive the transfer regulation to permit eligibility
only at the sub-varsity level during the first semester of the
1999-00 school year was made on behalf of a 9th-grade student
who is the daughter of a Capac High School teacher and who enrolled
Oct. 25, 1999, having previously attended Grand Blanc High School
where she did not participate in any school athletics.
The Executive
Committee granted the request for waiver.
Carson City-Crystal High School
(Regulation I, Section 9[B]) -
Request to waive the transfer regulation to permit eligibility
only at the sub-varsity level during the first semester of the
1999-00 school year was made on behalf of a 9th-grade student
who, prior to Nov. 8, 1999, attended Carson City Fellowship Baptist
School where she did not participate in any sport in which the
MHSAA conducts a postseason tournament.
The Executive Committee granted
the request for waiver.
Decatur
High School (Regulation I, Section 9) - A
late request to waive the transfer regulation was made on behalf
of an 11th-grade student who in both 9th and 10th grades spent
the first semester at Decatur High School and the second semester
at Paw Paw High School. Noting there have now been four school
changes and that there has been no indication why the transfers
were caused by or necessary for treatment of medical conditions,
the Executive Committee denied the request for waiver at its Oct.
13, 1999 meeting.
Based
on the additional information submitted, the Executive Committee
granted the request for waiver.
Detroit-St.
Martin De Porres High School (Regulation I, Section 9) - Request to waive the transfer
regulation was made on behalf of a 12th-grade student who transferred
to De Porres in September of 1999, having previously attended
Detroit-Kettering. On Sept. 22, while in his home, the student
was the object of a handgun attack related to a school situation.
He relocated to his aunt and uncle's home and transferred to De
Porres Sept. 27. At its Nov. 17, 1999 meeting, the Executive Committee
tabled this item pending receipt of additional information.
Based on the
additional information submitted, the Executive Committee granted
the request for waiver.
Pontiac-Notre
Dame Preparatory (Regulation I, Section 9[B]) - Request to waive the transfer
regulation to permit eligibility only at the sub-varsity level
was made on behalf of a 10th-grade student who enrolled Sept.
16, 1999, having previously attended Rochester-Adams High School
where he did not participate in any sports.
The Executive Committee granted
the request for waiver.
Sturgis
High School (Regulation I, Section 9) -
Sturgis High School requested assistance with interpreting the
eligibility of a student who was home schooled prior to the 1998-99
school year when he enrolled at Sturgis-Lake Area Christian School.
During the second semester, he took a three-hour building trades
class at Sturgis High School through the St. Joseph County ISD
program which required the student be enrolled at Sturgis. The
student has enrolled full-time at Sturgis High School for 1999-00.
The Executive
Committee determined that the student did not meet the requirement
of the transfer regulation and that waiver should not be granted.
Tawas City-Tawas
Area High School (Regulation I, Section 9) -
Request to waive the transfer regulation was made on behalf of
an 11th-grade student who attended Tawas Area High School while
living with his family in Tawas. On Oct. 4, 1999, he transferred
to Beaverton High School where his father has a business and a
second residence where he stayed with his father during the week.
All are now living in Tawas where the student re-enrolled Nov.
8.
Because
of the short duration and lack of participation and because the
student has returned to the same residence and school, the Executive
Committee granted the request for waiver.
Wyoming-Kelloggsville High School
(Regulation I, Section 9[B]) -
Request to waive the transfer regulation to permit eligibility
only at the sub-varsity level during the first semester of the
1999-00 school year was made on behalf of a 9th-grade student
who previously attended Academy of Health and Science where he
did not participate in any MHSAA tournament sponsored sports program.
The Executive
Committee granted the request for waiver.
Dryden High School (Regulation
V, Section 3[C]) -
An Oct. 1, 1999 varsity football game at Armada High School was
ended by officials with 6:05 remaining in the third quarter because
of sportsmanship problems the officials attributed to Dryden High
School, whose principal submitted a written report of the school's
follow-up, which included meetings with ejected players, meetings
with coaches and sportsmanship drills for the team. At its Nov.
17, 1999 meeting, the Executive Committee accepted the school's
follow-up except with respect to coaches, requesting that more
information be provided by the school, which was subsequently
received.
The
Executive Committee accepted the school's action without the requirement
of an appearance at a future meeting.
Lansing-Sexton High School (Classification)
- Request was
made to waive the Aug. 15 deadline for notification of desire
to compete in Division 1 of the MHSAA Wrestling Tournaments, which
until this year was where the school's enrollment placed it.
Noting that
Division 1 is where the school has participated in the past and
intends to participate in 2000-01, the Executive Committee granted
the request for the school to participate in 1999-00 MHSAA Wrestling
Tournaments.
Inkster
High School -
At its August 1997 meeting, the Executive Committee reviewed the
record of MHSAA Handbook violations by this school and determined
that the 1997-98 membership of Inkster High School be held in
abeyance until its superintendent, principal and athletic director
met at the MHSAA office with the executive director to show cause
why the school's membership should not be suspended or its membership
privileges not be reduced. At its September 1997 meeting, the
Executive Committee reviewed the actions of Inkster High School
to eliminate the violations of Handbook policies and procedures
that have plagued the school in recent years, accepted the school's
membership for 1997-98, and requested the executive director provide
at the Executive Committee's June 1998 meeting a review of Inkster
High School's compliance record during 1997-98. At that meeting,
it was reported that one violation, failure to rate any boys basketball
officials during the 1997-98 season, was known to have occurred
during the 1997-98 school year. At its June 10, 1998 meeting,
the Executive Committee determined to continue the school's probationary
status through the 1998-99 school year and requested that the
executive director report to the Executive Committee in June 1999
about the school's compliance efforts during that year. After
that report to the Executive Committee, Inkster High School had
two violations: (1) Regulation II, Section 8(B) - failure to attend
a Boys Tennis Rules Meeting or the head coach to pass the rules
examination; and (2) Regulation II, Section 7(B) - failure to
rate any officials in girls volleyball. In addition, the MHSAA
had been contacted by the United Federation of Officials about
failure by Inkster Public Schools to pay officials.
At its June 9, 1999 meeting,
the Executive Committee determined that Inkster High School remain
on probation through the 1999-00 school year and that the executive
director communicate with the school's administration about the
two violations and ways to improve its procedures for payments
to officials. After that, Inkster had these additional violations
for 1998-99:
Baseball
- failure to rate any officials.
Softball
- failure of head coach to attend rules meeting or pass exam.
Softball - failure
to rate any officials.
At
the Aug. 18, 1999 meeting of the Executive Committee, it was requested
that the executive director express the concern of the Executive
Committee directly to the superintendent and board president,
as well as principal and athletic director of Inkster High School,
and that recommendations be prepared for the Representative Council
for publicizing chronic offenders and penalizing them in ways
that affect financial reimbursements, hosting opportunities, and
participation opportunities for students of schools which are
chronic offenders of administrative rules. The only response was
a Sept. 16 telephone call from the new athletic director to inquire
what she needed to do. Therefore, at its Oct. 13, 1999 meeting,
the Executive Committee requested that MHSAA staff meet with the
new athletic director, other administrators and board members
regarding the association's expectations for institutional control
over its program. Subsequently, the athletic director resigned
and another was appointed.
The
latest event of concern was the failure of Inkster High School
to show for its MHSAA Girls Basketball District Tournament game
at River Rouge on Nov. 18, 1999.
On
Nov. 23, 1999, the new athletic director, interim superintendent
and a board of education member met with three MHSAA staff to
review problems and solutions.
The
Executive Committee voted to continue probation for Inkster High
School through the 2000-01 school year and requested staff continue
to monitor the school's administration of its interscholastic
athletic program.
Representative
Council - The
Executive Committee reviewed the schedule and agenda for the Dec.
1, 1999 meeting.
Next
Meetings - The
next meeting of the Executive Committee is Wednesday, Jan. 19,
at 9 a.m. in East Lansing. Thereafter, the committee will meet
Wednesday, Feb. 16, at 9 a.m. in East Lansing (with the Finance
Committee Meeting to follow); Thursday, March 23, at 9 a.m. in
East Lansing; Wednesday, April 19, at 9 a.m. in East Lansing (with
the Finance Committee Meeting to follow); Saturday, May 6, at
6:15 p.m. in Gaylord; and Wednesday, June 14, at 9 a.m. in East
Lansing. n
REPRESENTATIVE COUNCIL MEETING
Grand Rapids, December
2, 1999
Presentation
- Pat Richardson
of Grass Lake and Jim Okler of Grosse Ile, both representing the
Michigan Interscholastic Track Coaches Association, addressed
the Representative Council on classification of track and field
and cross country, the details of a Team Track and Field Meet,
and the date for the Regional and Final Cross Country Tournaments.
Accounts
of Meetings -
Motion by William Newkirk, supported by Randy Salisbury, to approve
the following accounts of meetings:
Representative Council Meeting
of May 2-4, 1999;
Executive
Committee Meeting of May 1, 1999, with the following corrections
as they appeared in the August 1999 Bulletin on page 19,
lines 19 to end of left column and lines 1-24 of right column:
"Watervliet-Grace Christian
High School (Regulation I, Section 1[D]) - Request
was made to waive the enrollment regulation to permit the school
to allow 8th grade girls to participate in sub-varsity basketball
in the 1999 season. The school's enrollment was 84 for 1998-99
and will be 82 for 1999-00.
"The
Executive Committee denied the request for waiver and referred
to the Representative Council consideration of raising the 75-student
threshold for 8th-graders' participation.
"Madison Heights-Bishop
Foley High School (Regulation I, Section 9[B]) - Request to waive the transfer
regulation to permit eligibility at the sub-varsity level was
made on behalf of a 9th-grade student who enrolled at Bishop Foley
on Nov. 17, 1998, and did not participate in school sports at
her previous high school but who did play in six junior varsity
girls soccer matches this spring before it was discovered she
is ineligible. The school has forfeited those six contests. If
waiver were granted, the school would withhold this student from
six contests.
"The
Executive Committee granted the request to waive the regulation
to permit the student to participate at the sub-varsity level
during the remainder of the 1998-99 school year after the student
is withheld from six contests.
"Monroe-St. Mary Catholic
Central High School (Regulation I, Section 9) - Request to waive the transfer
regulation was made on behalf of a student of divorced parents
who attended parochial schools in Erie, Michigan through 8th grade,
attended Temperance-Bedford High School for 9th grade in 1997-98,
relocated to his father's residence and attended 10th grade at
Vicksburg High School in 1998-99, and has registered for St. Mary
Catholic Central High School for 11th grade in 1999-00 when he
will return to his mother's residence. He played football at Vicksburg
without an Educational Transfer Form being filed.
"The Executive Committee
denied the request for waiver.
"Regulation I, Section
9 - The Executive
Committee determined that Interpretation No. 60 does not apply
to a student who registers for a school but has not enrolled and
attended class when his/her family move into a new public school
district. The 'catch-up provision' of No. 60 affects only those
students who are enrolled at and are attending class at one school
when their parent(s) relocates from one school district to another."
Executive
Committee Meeting of June 9, 1999, with the following change to
the August Bulletin, page 21, left column, lines 34-40:
"Napoleon,
East Jackson and Manchester High Schools (Regulation I, Section
1[E]) - The
Executive Committee approved the addition of Manchester High School
to a cooperative program that originally included Napoleon, East
Jackson, Vandercook Lake and Brooklyn-Columbia Central. Vandercook
Lake and Columbia Central withdrew involvement for 1998-99. Napoleon
remains the primary school. The combined enrollment is 1,259."
Executive
Committee Meetings of Aug. 18, Sept. 15, Oct. 13, and Nov. 17
1999;
Upper
Peninsula Athletic Committee Meetings of Sept. 24 and Nov. 4,
1999;
Board
of Canvassers Meetings of Sept. 17 and Oct. 6, 1999.
Adopted.
REPORTS
Legislation - The executive director reported
that there were no efforts to resuscitate the legislative initiatives
of the previous spring which would have allowed unenrolled students
to participate on school sports teams and resulted in forceful
opposition by school boards, administrators, coaches and parents.
He reported that a bill had passed the Senate and House and signed
by the Governor (Public Act 187) to prohibit the promotion or
distribution by public school employees and volunteers of dietary
supplements that claim to enhance athletic performance, including
androstenedione and creatine.
Litigation
- Attorney Edmund
Sikorski updated Council members on the status of two legal actions
in progress in which the MHSAA is a defendant.
Administration - The executive director reviewed
plans for the MHSAA Annual Business Meeting on Dec. 2, 1999.
The executive director reported
that during the fall, the MHSAA had provided 26 "mini-grants"
for sportsmanship initiatives at the league or local level, totaling
$9,530 and, in addition, had provided $9,000 to the Ruster Foundation
for sportsmanship initiatives, including a $5,000 general use
grant and twenty $200 grants to support specific local initiatives
that were not already being supported financially by the MHSAA.
In total, the MHSAA had provided $18,530. Not counting the $5,000
general use gift to the Ruster Foundation, the MHSAA helped to
support financially 46 different sportsmanship events, involving
approximately 400 schools and more than 5,000 students.
Results of the
1999 Update Meeting survey were reviewed by the executive director,
with special attention given to responses to survey questions
relating to items on the Representative Council's agenda.
The November survey of tennis
schools indicated support for No. 4 doubles in the MHSAA Regional
and Final Tennis Tournaments, which will be an action item for
the Representative Council's May agenda.
It was reported that the closing
date for the fourth and final available parcel of Ramblewood Park
Condominium has been delayed until late January and that the purchaser
is being required to pay the association $3,888 to have the closing
delayed.
The
1999 Football Playoffs, for which the field of qualifying teams
had been doubled to 256, was briefly reviewed with the indication
that the expanded format had met most peoples' objectives including
increasing the number of qualifying teams, inclusion of more teams
with strong winning records and excluding teams with losing records,
and equalizing the percentage of schools which qualify for the
Football Playoffs in each of the four classes. Ideas for improvement
of the Football Playoffs will be considered by the MHSAA Football
Committee in January and presented to the Representative Council
at its March or May meeting.
OLD BUSINESS
Authenticating Mark - At its meeting Dec. 2, 1998,
the Representative Council determined that the National Federation
Authenticating Mark would not be required on any game ball for
any sport on any level in 1999-00 involving MHSAA member schools,
and that this topic would be revisited in December 1999. It is
now apparent that most manufacturers will have a high school product
stamped by the 2000-01 school year, raise their prices 50 cents
and send 25 cents the National Federation. It is likely that schools
still will have inventory of unstamped balls to use in 2000-01.
Motion by Randy
Salisbury, supported by Dan Flynn, that the Representative Council
make no change in MHSAA policy for 2000-01 (the Authenticating
Mark will not be required for any contest on any level in any
sport) and that the Council review this topic again at its December
2000 meeting. Adopted.
Ice
Hockey - In
March of 1999, the Representative Council reviewed concerns for
conduct during the 1998-99 ice hockey season and voted to convene
in April a meeting of 1999 MHSAA District, Regional and Final
Tournament Managers and others to address ice hockey conduct concerns,
to bring a report of that meeting to the Representative Council
in May and to consider some additional actions. In May of 1999,
the Representative Council heard about the successful April meeting
and voted that attendance by a school's athletic director, principal
or superintendent at a meeting held 30 minutes prior to the regular
rules meetings at one of seven sites would be an entry requirement
for the 1999-00 MHSAA Ice Hockey Tournament.
On Sept. 29, 1999, the MHSAA
Ice Hockey Committee approved the agenda for those meetings that
were held in October, and also adopted the recommendation that
the MHSAA sponsor annually at its office an in-service program
for schools and coaches new to hockey with guest presenters from
member schools including administrators, coaches and officials.
Motion
by Eric Federico, supported by Gerry David, to approve such meetings
on a voluntary basis as a service to schools which are new to
their sponsorship of ice hockey. Adopted.
Non-Traditional Schools and
Students - The
Representative Council reviewed the results of three task forces
which conducted meetings, open to the public, in three parts of
Michigan, for the purpose of considering ways to better promote
the options that currently exist for students who are less than
full time at a particular school to participate in interscholastic
athletics for that school, and to also consider ideas for expanding
those opportunities. The consensus of the task force meetings
and the overwhelming sentiment in responses to the 1999 MHSAA
Update Meeting survey was that no additional opportunities need
to be created by the MHSAA. However, the Council did suggest that
the summary of policies that had been provided at the Update Meetings
be distributed to superintendents, athletic director, principals
and counselors of schools, to ISDs, and to the Department of Education.
Classification
- Mr. Alto and
Mr. Flynn reported that consensus is lacking but progress is being
made on the subject of classification of MHSAA Upper Peninsula
tournaments. It is expected that a recommendation may be made
to the Representative Council for its May meeting, and the staff
will provide a history of Upper Peninsula tournaments at that
time.
Motion
by Keith Eldred, supported by Tom Rashid, to implement the 20
percent modification, effective with the 2000-01 school year,
to reduce the enrollment range in Division 4 of the MHSAA Boys
and Girls Soccer Tournaments. Adopted.
Motion by Keith Eldred, supported
by Norm Johnson, to reclassify the MHSAA Lower Peninsula Boys
and Girls Track and Field and Cross Country Tournaments into four
equal divisions. Adopted. Pursuant to Representative Council action
in May of 1999, this is effective with the spring, 2000 MHSAA
Track and Field Meet.
Team
Track and Field Meet -
Pursuant to Representative Council directive last May, staff provided
a presentation of the possible formats and impact of an MHSAA
Lower Peninsula Team Track and Field Meet. Discussion ensued.
Softball
Venue - At its
December 1998 meeting, the Representative Council expressed support
of the MHSAA's participation in enhancement of softball facilities
at the Bailey Park complex in Battle Creek. Enhancements of the
bleachers, dugout, press box and fencing (including permanent
outfield fencing at approximately 225 feet for the championship
diamond) have been estimated to cost $205,000. The City of Battle
Creek Park and Recreation Department has set aside $85,000 to
assist.
Motion
by Paul Ellinger, supported by Randy Salisbury, that the MHSAA
pledge $60,000, payable over two years and in exchange for waiver
of facility expenses and fees related to the MHSAA Softball Finals
for a minimum of six years after completion. Adopted.
Basketball - The Council considered the
negative impact on the business and administration of the MHSAA
of conducting the MHSAA Boys Basketball Semifinals and Finals
during traditional vacation periods and also of rescheduling the
Boys Basketball Tournament so, for example, District and Regional
Boys Basketball Tournaments would coincide with Girls Volleyball
Districts and Regionals and Regional Boys Basketball Tournaments
would coincide with MHSAA Final Tournaments in Girls Gymnastics,
Ice Hockey, Swimming and Diving and Individual Wrestling.
Motion by William Newkirk, supported
by Joyce Seals, that the staff examine alternative schedules for
winter tournaments in 2005 but that no tournament occur on Easter
weekend. Adopted.
NEW BUSINESS
Golf Cooperative Programs -
Regulation I,
Section 1(F) allows cooperative programs without regard to a maximum
combined enrollment of the schools involved for sports that are
sponsored by 250 or fewer schools. There are currently 257 schools
which sponsor girls golf, including 36 in the Upper Peninsula
and several in the Lower Peninsula which historically have not
completed the season or entered the MHSAA post-season tournament.
At its Aug. 18, 1999 meeting, the Executive Committee determined
that cooperative program applications in girls golf would continue
to be accepted for processing without regard to the Class B enrollment
maximum until the Oct. 15, 1999 deadline for the spring sport
cooperative programs, and that the Representative Council should
provide guidance for the future.
Motion
by Paul Ellinger, supported by Joyce Seals, that the Executive
Committee continue to have the authority to approve cooperative
programs in girls golf until the total number of Lower Peninsula
girls golf programs reaches 250. Adopted.
Administrative Violations and
Penalties - At
its Aug. 18, 1999 meeting, the Executive Committee requested that
the Representative Council consider the possibility of publishing
in the MHSAA Bulletin the names of schools whose head coaches
fail to attend rules meetings or pass the examination and imposing
penalties that reduce or eliminate MHSAA tournament reimbursements,
hosting opportunities and participation privileges.
Motion by Mike Shibler, supported
by Joyce Seals, that the MHSAA Bulletin list the names of schools
whose head coaches fail to attend a rules meeting or pass the
examination and that further consideration of other actions be
delayed until the December 2000 meeting of the Representative
Council. Adopted.
Regular-Season
Contest Delays -
Motion by William Newkirk, supported by Eric Federico, to approve
the following policy when a league or conference does not have
a written policy regarding late contest start times:
When a league or conference
does not have a written policy regarding late contest start time,
the following MHSAA policy will apply:
1. If a team fails to arrive
for a regular season contest at the time stated on the contract,
it will be necessary for the host administration to delay the
contest, declare the game forfeited, reschedule the contest, or
declare the event "no contest."
2. If the host management has
been notified of the reason for the delay and projected arrival,
the officials must stand by for 60 minutes beyond the scheduled
starting time. When the team arrives, a reasonable amount of time
must be provided for the visiting team to conduct a pregame warm-up.
In any case, warm-up may not be less than 15 minutes.
3. If the host management has
not been notified that there is a delay and the reason for it,
the officials have permission to leave the site, without obligation,
30 minutes after the contracted start time has passed.
In
MHSAA tournament play, the General Information Bulletin for each
sport will prescribe the specific action to be taken.
Adopted.
MIAAA Exemplary Athletic Program
- Motion by
Randy Salisbury, supported by Paul Ellinger, that the MHSAA make
its Football Finals available as the venue for honoring those
schools whose athletic programs are designated "exemplary
programs" through the self-assessment program developed by
the Michigan Interscholastic Athletic Administrators Association.
Adopted.
National
Federation Rule Publications - Motion
by Tom Rashid, supported by Eric Federico, to continue the policy
of providing National Federation rule books to member schools
and officials. Adopted.
Awards
- Associate
Director Jerry Cvengros reported that there were nine nominees
for the 11th Women in Sports Leadership Award and that the Awards
Committee narrowed the candidates to four, which were presented
to the Representative Council. Council members were asked to vote
for one candidate. The name of the recipient will be released
at an appropriate time and the recipient will be honored during
the awards luncheon of the 2000 Women in Sports Leadership Conference.
Mr. Cvengros
reported that there were 13 nominees for the Charles E. Forsythe
Award and that the Awards Committee narrowed the candidates to
five, which were presented to the Representative Council members
for a ballot vote. The names of the recipients will be released
at an appropriate time and the recipients will be honored during
the 2000 Class B Boys Basketball Finals Tournament game.
Motion by William
Newkirk, supported by Joyce Seals, to approve the Awards Committee
recommendation that MHSAA staff be allowed to vote with the Awards
Committee for candidates for presentation to the Council for the
Allen W. Bush Award. Adopted.
Meeting
Expenses - Expenses
for this meeting were approved at the specified hotel rates for
accommodations and parking, the IRS specified meal allowance and
a 30¢ per mile mileage allowance round-trip.
Future Meetings - The next meeting of the Representative
Council will be held on Friday, March 24, 2000, 8:15 a.m. at the
MHSAA building in East Lansing. The spring meeting of the Representative
Council will be May 7-9, 2000, at Marsh Ridge in Gaylord.
The meeting
was adjourned. n
REPRESENTATIVE
COUNCIL MEETING
Grand
Rapids, December 1, 1999
Election
of Officers -
Officers elected to serve through the fall, 2000 meeting of the
Representative Council were President Paul Ellinger, Vice-President
Dennis Kniola, and Secretary-Treasurer Tom Rashid.
The president appointed Dan
Flynn to serve on the Executive Committee on a regular basis during
2000, with the fifth position filled on a rotating basis by other
Council members.
William
Newkirk and Michael Shibler were invited to serve with the president
and secretary-treasurer on the MHSAA Finance Committee for 2000.
Selection
of Appointed Members - According
to the MHSAA Constitution, "It is the annual responsibility
of the Council to ascertain that the Council elective process
has provided for the representation of females and minorities.
If, in the judgment of the Council, these results have not been
achieved, said Council shall appoint not to exceed four Representative
Council members-at-large for two-year terms."
The Representative Council appointed
Melvin Atkins, Director of Athletics for the Grand Rapids Public
Schools, and Judy Raica, Principal at North Branch High School,
to two-year terms on the Representative Council.
Council members and staff expressed
gratitude to two retiring Council members, Robert Grimes and Geraldine
David.
The
meeting was adjourned. n
ATKINS AND RAICA APPOINTED TO COUNCIL
It is the annual
responsibility of the Representative Council of the Michigan High
School Athletic Association to ascertain that the Council elective
process has provided for representation of females and minorities.
If, in the judgment of the Council, these results have not been
achieved, the Council may appoint up to four (total) members-at-large
for two-year terms.
As
a result, on Dec. 1, 1999, the MHSAA Representative Council appointed
Melvin Atkins, Director of Athletics for the Grand Rapids
Public Schools, and Judy Raica, Principal at North Branch
High School.
The
two other appointed members are Dewayne Jones, Athletic
Director at West Bloomfield High School, and Earl Rickman
who serves on the Mt. Clemens Board of Education.n
Paul Ellinger, Superintendent of Cheboygan
Area Schools, was elected President of the MHSAA Representative
Council for 2000 at the Council's Dec. 1, 1999, meeting in Grand
Rapids. He has served on the Representative Council for 14 years
while serving the school districts of Deerfield, Beal City and
Hartford.
Reelected
Vice-President for 2000 was Dennis Kniola, Principal of
Stevensville-Lakeshore Middle School, who has served on the Council
for 15 years, from 1983 to 1985 and from 1986 to present.
Reelected Secretary-Treasurer
was Tom Rashid, who has served as the private and parochial
school representative on the Council since 1988. Mr. Rashid is
Director of Health, Athletics, Physical Education and Safety for
the Archdiocese of Detroit.
Mr.
Ellinger has appointed 11-year Council veteran Dan Flynn
of Escanaba to serve as the permanent member of the MHSAA Executive
Committee for 2000. The fifth position on the Executive Committee
rotates from meeting to meeting.
Appointed
by the President to serve on the Finance Committee with him and
the Secretary-Treasurer during 2000 were William Newkirk,
Superintendent at Sanford-Meridian Public Schools, and Michael
Shibler, Superintendent at Rockford Public Schools. Mr. Newkirk
has served on the Representative Council for 11 years; Mr. Shibler
has served 4 years. n
ANNUAL BUSINESS MEETING OF THE MHSAA
Grand Rapids, December 2, 1999
The Annual Business
Meeting of the Michigan High School Athletic Association was held
at the Grand Traverse Resort in Traverse City on Thursday morning,
Dec. 2, 1999, in conjunction with a breakfast provided by the
MHSAA for attendees at the annual convention of the Michigan Association
of Secondary School Principals.
MHSAA
Representative Council President Paul Ellinger presided. Tom Rashid,
Secretary-Treasurer, commented briefly on the budget for 1999-00
and on the audit for the fiscal year ending July 31, 1999.
Executive Director
John E. Roberts reviewed the 1998-99 program year of the MHSAA
(see page 358 of this Bulletin). He also provided highlights of
the Council meeting of Dec. 1, 1999; and recognized Robert Grimes
for his 16 years of Council service, including three years as
President.n
REPORT OF ACTIVITIES OF THE MICHIGAN
HIGH SCHOOL ATHLETIC ASSOCIATION, INC. SCHOOL YEAR - 1998-99
PUBLICATIONS - Monthly Bulletin distributed
to junior and senior high schools and registered officials; Officials
Directory and School Directory and calendars prepared;
Book of Champions published; MHSAA Handbook distributed
to junior and senior high schools; rule books for football, basketball,
track, swimming, wrestling, gymnastics, soccer, softball, spirit,
ice hockey, volleyball, and baseball distributed to schools and
registered officials; blanks and forms were distributed to schools.
Stripes and Mentor were published and distributed to all registered
officials and head coaches, respectively. The Officials' Guidebook
was published for distribution to all prospective officials. The
Coaches Guidebook was published and distributed to all
schools. The Competitive Cheer Manual was published for
the sixth time.
RULES
MEETINGS/CLINICS - General
meetings and rules meetings held in baseball/softball, competitive
cheer, football, basketball, swimming and diving, tennis, track
and field, golf, wres-tling, gymnastics, volleyball, soccer, and
ice hockey for coaches and registered officials. The Officials
Awards and Alumni Banquet honored 20 and 30-year officials. Special
meetings were conducted for coaches association presidents and
league and conference executives. Tournament managers meetings
were held in most sports. Meetings were held with representatives
of local officials associations. An ad hoc Officials Review Committee
was convened to develop initiatives to better serve and support
officials, local officials associations and officials assignors.
In-service programs for officials assignors and sessions to train
the basketball, football, volleyball, wrestling, soccer, baseball
and softball trainers of approved officials associations were
conducted. The 11th Women in Sports Leadership Conference was
held. Meetings for competitive cheer judges and coaches were held
separately across the state for the sixth time.
COMMITTEES - Over 300 different individuals
served on Association committees during the 1998-99 school year.
PARTICIPANTS
- Approximately
256,000 students were members of interscholastic athletic squads
of the 731 member high schools during the 1998-99 school year.
REGISTERED
OFFICIALS -
There were 11,066 officials registered in one or more sports during
the year.
UPDATE
MEETINGS - Meetings
for 1,221 people were conducted during the fall in Frankenmuth,
Kalamazoo, East Lansing, Gaylord, Pontiac, Comstock Park and Marquette.
PACE
SEMINARS - There
were approximately 775 participants who completed one or more
courses in the Program of Athletic Coaches' Education at sites
throughout the state during the 1998-99 school year.
ATHLETIC DIRECTORS IN-SERVICE
- 284 athletic
directors participated in the Athletic Directors In-Service programs
at nine sites throughout the state during August 1998. n
REPRESENTATIVE COUNCIL & U.P. ATHLETIC
COMMITTEE
NOMINATION PROCEDURES FOR 2000-01
The Representative Council has
established procedures for indicating the intention to run for
elected positions on the MHSAA Representative Council.
1. Any individual who is a representative
of a member school (administrator, faculty member or board of
education member) may submit his or her name to the MHSAA office
by March 15.
A.
Candidates must have superintendent or principal approval in writing.
B.
It is essential that candidates be qualified for the position
they seek.
1)
If the position is for a representative of a certain area of the
state, they must represent a school of the appropriate class (A
and B or C and D) in that geographic area.
2) If they seek the position
of a statewide at large representative, they must be a faculty
or board of education member of an MHSAA member school. This includes
administrators but not non-faculty coaches.
3) If they seek the position
of statewide representative of junior high/middle schools or private
and parochial high schools, they must be faculty (teacher or administrator)
or board members for such schools.
2. Names submitted will be published
in the May Bulletin and typed on the ballot mailed to member
schools in September.
Elections
will be held in the fall for the following positions:
Class A and B Schools--3 openings
Northern Lower Peninsula
Southwestern
Section
Southeastern
Section
Class
C and D Schools--2
openings
Upper
Peninsula
Northern
Lower Peninsula
Statewide
At-Large--1
opening statewide
Junior
High/Middle Schools--1
opening
Private
and Parochial--1
opening
The
procedures established for indicating the intention to run for
elected positions are the same for the Upper Peninsula Athletic
Committee as those stated above for the Representative Council.
Elections
will be held in the fall for the following:
Class D U.P. School--1 opening
Athletic Coach--1 opening n
MEMBERSHIP NOMINATIONS
A procedure has been adopted
by the Representative Council to select MHSAA committee members.
In the early spring of 2000, all superintendents, principals,
athletic directors, and coaches who desire to serve on MHSAA committees
may submit their names for nomination. This is a summary of the
make-up and responsibilities of MHSAA standing committees:
DESCRIPTION OF MHSAA COMMITTEES
SPORT
COMMITTEES
1.
Consist of a balance of administrators and varsity coaches in
the particular sport, plus the president of the coaches association
for that sport.
2.
Responsible for:
(a)
recommending to the Representative Council changes regarding MHSAA
regulations relative to the sport.
(b) recommending to the staff
procedures, sites, and assignments for the MHSAA tournament in
that sport.
Baseball/Softball,
Basketball, Comp. Cheer, Cross Country/Track & Field, Football,
Golf, Gymnastics, Ice Hockey, Skiing, Soccer, Swimming & Diving,
Tennis, Volleyball, Wrestling
TOURNAMENT COMMITTEES
1.
Consist of administrators.
2.
Responsible for selecting sites and assigning teams for all levels
of MHSAA tournaments in the particular sport.
Girls & Boys Basketball
(meets twice),
Cross Country/Track & Field Site Selection, Track & Field
Standards
SEEDING COMMITTEES
1. Consist of tournament managers
and varsity coaches.
2.
Responsible for determining seeded players and their positions
in each flight and for assisting the tournament managers in conducting
the tournament draw. Must have knowledge of players statewide
and rules for making the draw.
Girls Tennis Area Seeding Directors,
Boys Tennis Area Seeding Directors
OFFICIAL SELECTION COMMITTEES
1.
Consist of tournament managers, athletic directors and coaches.
2.
Responsible for selecting officials for most levels of tournaments
in most sports.
Baseball,
Boys Basketball, Girls Basketball, Competitive Cheer, Football,
Girls Gymnastics, Ice Hockey, Boys Soccer, Girls Soccer, Girls
Softball, Girls Volleyball, Wrestling.
OTHER STANDING COMMITTEES (Established and appointed by
the Representative Council for specific purposes)
1. Athletic Equity Committee
-- Committee is to meet once a year to recommend to the Representative
Council annual objectives designed to encourage participation
by more women and minorities in interscholastic coaching, officiating,
and administrative positions.
2. Awards Committee --
This committee meets once as a group and corresponds throughout
the year to establish policies and procedures and screen candidates
for four MHSAA awards: Forsythe, Bush, Norris, and Women in Sports
Leadership.
3.
Classification Committee -- The committee meets annually
to study and make recommendations to staff and Council regarding
policies and procedures of classifying schools for tournaments
and elections. It consists of two representatives each from MASB,
MASA, MASSP and MIAAA, plus other appointees to assume adequate
representation of all sizes and types of schools.
4. Board of Canvassers --
Comprised of a superintendent, two high school principals, one
junior high/middle school principal and one athletic director.
Members are responsible for counting the ballots for the election
of Representative Council members and members of the Upper Peninsula
Athletic Committee. Generally, the committee meets only once,
but in the event of ties or runoffs, the entire committee or a
portion of the committee returns to count runoff ballots.
5. Junior High/Middle School
Committee -- This committee is comprised of junior high/middle
school principals and athletic directors to review rules and regulations
as they pertain to junior high/middle schools.
6. Scholar-Athlete Committee
-- Established to administer the MHSAA Scholar-Athlete program,
this committee consists of approximately 30 people who agree to
attend two of three scheduled meetings each year and review award
applications through correspondence.
Criteria for Nomination and Selection of MHSAA
Committee Members
There are several criteria to
consider before completing the Nomination Form:
1. Coaches should be on the
school faculty and able to obtain release time from school.
2.
The nominee should have at least two years of experience in the
position currently holding.
3. Most committees require only
a one meeting date commitment at the MHSAA building in East Lansing.
Committee meetings are held during the work week.
Appointments to committees are
based on the following criteria:
1. Committees should have male,
female, and minority membership which reflects the total pool
of available personnel.
2.
Committees should maintain geographic and class size representation.
3.
Some administrators will be appointed to sport committees.
4.
The coaches association president/secretary of each sport is appointed
to that sport committee, if the person is a school employee. If
the President/Secretary is not a school employee, the Association
must send a designee who is an administrator, faculty member or
board of education member of an MHSAA member school.
Names of nominees will be submitted
to the Representative Council for selection.
Over 300 people will be selected
from the list of nominees submitted to serve on 38 MHSAA committees.
FROM
THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR THINKING INSIDE THE BOX
Recently I was
asked what I foresaw for interscholastic athletics and the Michigan
High School Athletic Association in the new year/decade ahead.
I responded
that there was no policy or program that I had a burning desire
to initiate. Rather, I hoped the MHSAA and its constituents would
focus in the future on the same critical issues that have defined
school sports throughout the past hundred years.
If so, we would give continuing
special attention to scholarship, sportsmanship,
safety and the scope of our programs. We would give
most attention to policies and programs that support the academic
mission of schools, encourage a civil and respectful environment
for competition, promote the physical well-being of participants,
and maintain limits on travel, seasons and out-of-season activities.
I hope at all
times and in all ways we will continue to focus on what the MHSAA
Handbook lists as our two primary purposes: (1) assisting
schools in their regulation of interscholastic athletics,
and (2) conducting postseason tournaments for their benefit.
I hope that
above all others we will continue to focus on two primary constituents:
(1) coaches, reaching even more coaches with an even broader
and deeper education program than the Program of Athletic Coaches'
Education is providing today, and (2) officials, equipping
local officials associations and their trainers and assignors
to do an even better job of recruiting, training, assigning and
evaluating contest officials.
Doing
the essentials better is what I hope for in the year 2000 and
beyond. Not thinking outside the box, but remaining in it, remembering
our first and fundamental reasons for being, and delivering the
very finest services that support those purposes.
It is possible that by thinking
outside the box, organizations forget about their reasons for
being. In interscholastic athletics, we would be well served to
think inside the box.
In
sports we learn we must compete within the confines of endlines
and sidelines. Go beyond the boundary lines and you're out of
play, where you can't score and can't win.
If school sports will secure
a victory for its future ­ meaning, school sports continue
to be a tool for schools to reach and motivate young people in
an educational setting ­ it will not occur from out of bounds.
It will occur because we stayed within prescribed boundaries:
local, amateur, educational, non-commercial, sportsmanlike and
physically beneficial. n
ANALYSIS
OF MHSAA MEMBERSHIP
January
1, 2000
736
Total High Schools
624
(85%) Total Public Schools
*19
(3%) Charter (Public School Academies)
*605 (82%) Traditional Schools
112 (15%)
Total Nonpublic Schools
*104
(14%) Religious
*8
(1%) Non-Secular
555 Total Junior High/Middle
Schools
492
(89%) Total Public Schools
*6
(1% Charter (Public School Academies)
*486 (88%) Traditional Schools
63 (11%)
Total Nonpublic Schools
*60
(11%) Religious
REVIEWING THE REGULATIONS SOUTHERN TRIPS MAY NOT INCLUDE COMPETITION
Each spring,
some of Michigan's high school spring sports teams head south
for warmer and drier weather in which to conduct practice; and
almost every year there are one or more schools discovered and
reported by others to be competing in violation of MHSAA regulations.
Handbook Interpretation No. 163 of MHSAA
Regulation II, Section 6 prohibits an MHSAA member school from
engaging in competition in any sport against any other school
if either team has traveled more than 600 highway miles round-trip.
The limitation
applies to both games and inter-school scrimmages (only
intrasquad games would be allowed) in all sports that conclude
with an MHSAA postseason tournament. The definition of scrimmage
includes practice sessions involving students from more than one
school. So MHSAA member schools must be certain not to schedule
any kind of competition and not to conduct practice at the same
time and place as another school.
Confirmed
violations of these regulations have been dealt with seriously
in the past in an effort to keep the playing field fair to those
schools which are committed to adhering to the rules they agreed
to adopt and enforce.
Schools
which desire to conduct practice sessions out of state at a site
more than 600 highway miles round-trip from their location must
complete and submit to the MHSAA office the "Out-of-State
Travel Declaration" form at least 30 days in advance of departure.
See MHSAA Handbook pages 48 and 102. n
NOTE:
Schools voluntarily
join the MHSAA and, to that end, it is necessary that each school
district sign each year a Membership Resolution adopting the rules
and regulations of the MHSAA as their own and agreeing to primary
enforcement of those rules. While a school district is not bound
by the decisions rendered by the MHSAA regarding rule violations,
the MHSAA may condition eligibility for its tournaments on compliance
with its rules and its determinations concerning rules violations
and the penalties to be imposed for violations of the rules. See
Attorney General Opinions No. 4795 (1977) and No. 6352 (1986).
Many school districts
have additional rules that may also apply to the subject matter
of this column.
MEMBER SCHOOL SHARES POLICY
ON ATHLETIC TRIPS Robert
Regan
Superintendent
Haslett Public Schools
As
often as possible, I like to remind students, parents, and the
community about the mission of the Haslett Public Schools: To
provide educational opportunities which enable students of all
aspirations and abilities to grow and learn. It's a mission that
energizes the efforts made every day by the Haslett Board of Education,
the district's administrators, teachers, and staff.
As we seek to provide different
opportunities for our students, we must bear in mind the costs
involved. We are keenly aware that these costs are borne mainly
by parents, not only in the form of their tax dollars, but also
when parents pay for athletic equipment, class trips, uniforms,
yearbooks, private music lessons, formal attire, as well as the
added expenses that come with a student's senior year of high
school.
Often
we rely on the generosity of businesses and individuals in our
community to help offset the expense of educational activities
through donations. At times, community fund raising becomes excessive.
Cost is an important
factor that we take into account when we receive requests from
student programs that go beyond the norm. This issue has been
brought to the forefront recently because of requests from some
Haslett interscholastic athletic programs to travel to the southern
United States in order to prepare for their upcoming sports seasons.
These requests are often supported and encouraged by parents.
There are many
factors that the district considers before approving out-of-state
travel requests. They are: Is the program educationally enriching?
Does it take students away from their families during a vacation
period? Does it pose a financial hardship? Does it ask too much
of the community in terms of fund raising? Does it heighten the
risk of liability? Are chaperones required? Does it have ramifications
for students who cannot afford to participate? We also must be
mindful of the precedent which is set when approving such a request.
If we approve a trip for one group, there is pressure to approve
requests from other groups.
After
careful consideration, the administration of the Haslett Public
Schools has determined that the disadvantages outweigh the potential
benefits that many of these trips have to offer. Therefore, the
Haslett Public Schools will adhere to the policy on interscholastic
athletic program travel established by the Michigan High School
Athletic Association. This means that we will apply this policy
to athletic practices as well as competition. Haslett teams may
travel to states adjoining Michigan which are Wisconsin, Indiana
and Ohio, as well as Ontario, Canada. Each request will be approved
on its own merit.
Without
a clear-cut policy, travel requests would continue to escalate.
Today, it's no longer unusual for athletic teams at some area
schools to travel across country-- and sometimes out of the country--to
practice in warmer climates. We believe this is extravagant and
unnecessary for athletic success.
Our
school district has an obligation to-and a partnership with-not
only students, but also parents and the community at large. We
believe that the MHSAA policy is reasonable, and benefits all
concerned. n
SOCCER, CROSS COUNTRY, TRACK & FIELD
RECLASSIFICATION OCCURS Reclassification
matters affecting soccer, cross country and track and field tournaments
were among the major actions taken by the Representative Council
of the Michigan High School Athletic Association at its Fall meeting,
Dec. 1, in Grand Rapids.
The
19-member legislative body of the Association's 1,300-plus member
schools meets three times annually to discuss and act upon sport
committee proposals, eligibility rules and procedural issues.
In soccer, the
Council voted to implement a 20 percent modification for the classification
of teams in those tournaments effective in 2000-01, in an effort
to reduce the enrollment range in the smallest classification.
Using the equal divisions concept this year, schools of 489 students
and under fall into Division 4 in boys soccer; and in girls soccer,
it is 643 students and below. If the 20 percent modification had
been in place, Division 4 for boys would have been 432 students
and below; for girls 578 and below. When this change takes affect
in the 2000-01 school year, there will be approximately 101 schools
in the Division 1-3 tournaments for boys, and 76 in the Division
4 tournament. For the girls soccer tournament, there will be approximately
84 schools in Divisions 1-3, and 63 in Division 4.
Since the expansion of the concept
of equal divisions in some MHSAA tournaments, there has been a
concern raised by some Class D schools regarding the enrollment
range between the largest and smallest school in the smallest
division for some sports. Last May, the Council went on record
in favor of reducing the enrollment range for the smallest schools'
division in at least some sports, and directed the MHSAA staff
to prepare classification modifications for at least some sports
broken into equal divisions.
"We
found that there is a need to monitor the enrollment range as
it relates to Class D schools. Considerations such as the type
of sport ­ non-contact, contact, collision ­ needed to
be factored into the equation, as well as the players required
for each sport," said John E. "Jack" Roberts, MHSAA
Executive Director. "During our research into this matter,
we found that the number of students participating in soccer from
Class C to Class D schools differed significantly, especially
when you consider the number of athletes necessary to field a
team, and the collision nature of the sport. We looked at several
methods of reducing the enrollment range and found that the 20
percent modification was the best fit."
The Council also added Lower
Peninsula track and field and cross country to the growing list
of MHSAA tournaments which utilize equal divisions. Effective
with the 2000 tournaments, equal divisions will be utilized, with
approximately 152 schools in each division for track and field;
approximately 139 schools in each division for cross country.
"The proposal
to reclassify track and field, as well as cross country, had strong
support of the committees for those sports, as well as that of
the classification committee and surveys of the membership,"
Roberts said. The Council had voted last May that if the equal
divisions concept was adopted for track and field, the change
would occur for the MHSAA's Spring 2000 Lower Peninsula Track
& Field Meet. n
FLINT NORTHWESTERN HONORED IN MHSAA "LEGENDS"
PROGRAM A
back-to-back winner of Michigan High School Athletic Association
Class A girls basketball championships in 1983 and 1984, Flint
Northwestern High School was honored through the Association's
"Legends Of The Games" program at ceremonies at halftime
of the Class A championship game of the 1999 Girls Basketball
Finals at Rose Arena in Mt. Pleasant on Dec. 4.
In its third year, the Legends
program promotes educational athletics by showcasing some of the
great teams of past years. Eight members of those teams were in
attendance to receive commemorative plaques and a banner to display
at the school during the ceremony.
The story that follows was written
by MHSAA Historian Ron Pesch of Muskegon, for this year's MHSAA
Girls Basketball Finals Souvenir Program.
For five seasons, Head Coach
Roger Zoll and his Flint Northwestern basketball squad patiently
waited for their turn. Each year, the lofty accomplishments of
their Saginaw Valley Conference rival, Flint Northern, overshadowed
the success of the Wildcats program.
For
half a decade, Northern had ended Northwestern's tournament dreams.
In four of those five seasons, 1978 to 1981, Northern finished
the year as Class A champions. In 1982, it earned MHSAA runner-up
honors. Sporting six seniors, Northern's 1983 squad was again
favored to make a sixth consecutive trip to the final round.
On the other
side of town, Zoll had assembled a starting five comprised of
all underclassmen. Led by juniors Taraisa Wills, Paulette Backstrom,
and Cynthia Lyons and sophomores Shanta Burks, and Tonya Edwards,
the Wildcats were young but experienced.
In 1982, they opened the season
with five consecutive victories before losing to Northern in game
six. The margin was 15 points, but Zoll's starting lineup included
only one senior. Edwards, a 5-8 freshman guard, scored 31 points
in that game. With a full season under her belt, Edwards was already
a highly regarded player.
Northwestern,
which opened its doors in the fall of 1964, had never won an MHSAA
title in any sport. The boys produced a pair of runner-ups in
the spring of 1975 - one in basketball and one in track. The girls
cage squad advanced to the 1975 quarterfinals before rise of Northern.
Once again,
the Wildcats recorded five straight victories before their conference
showdown with unbeaten Northern. Zoll's squad opened up a 31-11
lead midway through the second quarter, as Northern suffered from
poor shooting, fouls and turnovers. Northwestern fought off a
third quarter rally by the Vikings and coasted to a 60-46 before
a packed house. Edwards finished with a game-high 24 points and
five assists.
With
the win, Northwestern began its rapid assent to the top of the
state rankings. The Wildcats were unbeaten in 15 straight, but
the season was far from over. The rematch with Northern was the
first in a pair of formable tests.
The
second scheduled showdown with their cross-town nemesis was a
battle for first place in the conference. Northern, 11-3 overall,
was still smarting from the early season defeat - its only loss
in conference play. A crowd of 1,300 watched the host Vikings
jump out to a 17-2 lead in the first quarter and a 36-23 halftime
advantage. Yet, thanks to solid play and Northern foul trouble,
Northwestern roared back and exited the gym with a 68-57 victory.
Edwards notched 29 points, while Backstrom added 19 including
10 without a miss from the free throw line. Coming off the bench
to help the inside game, Wills added 14 points.
Four days later, Zoll's squad
met defending Class A champ, Farmington Our Lady of Mercy. Northwestern
watched Mercy erase an eight-point deficit in the final minute
of regulation and steal a 51-48 victory in overtime.
In the opening rounds of the
tournament, both Northern and Northwestern trounced their opponents
en route to the seemingly inevitable showdown in this civil war.
Edwards scored 12 in the first half, but the Vikings led 20-19
at the intermission. But once again, foul trouble doomed Northern.
Neither team shot well from the field, but the Wildcats were 18
of 30 from the charity stripe. Northern hit 2-of-4 from the free
throw line. Wills dominated the inside, scoring 10 of her 11 points
in the second stanza while senior Soroya Pendleton came off the
bench to score seven.
"We've
been knocking on the door," said Zoll after the game "Now
it's our turn."
Northwestern
disposed of Midland Dow and Flint Kearsley in the regionals and
after five years, the city of Flint was sending a new representative
to the quarterfinals.
A
win over Waterford Kettering set the stage for a rematch with
Farmington Mercy in the semis. The Marlins concentrated on shutting
down Edwards, holding the sophomore to 12 point. This time a new
underclassman emerged as the hero. Freshman guard Stephanie Tipton
nailed three 14-foot jump shots at the start of the fourth quarter
to lead the Wildcats to a 44-41 victory. Mercy, which had defeated
Northern in the championship contest a year previous with a fourth-quarter
rally, pulled to within a point with 2:46 to play. This time however,
Northwestern held the Marlins scoreless in their final four possessions
to advance to the final game. It was Zoll's 100th career coaching
victory.
With
a 50-47 win in the Class A Final, Northwestern had finally burst
into the spotlight. Harper Woods Regina, the opponent in the championship
game, nearly prevented the dream from coming true. The Saddlelites
had easily handled Northwestern's powerful press and led by four,
47-43, with 4:23 to play.
The
Wildcats buckled down defensively. Wills scored on a rebound to
pull within two. On the inbound pass, Backstrom came up with a
steal - her seventh of the game - and dished off to Edwards who
tied things up with 3:34 left. Cynthia Lyons added a free throw
with 58 seconds remaining to push the Wildcats into the lead.
A three-second
violation called on Regina forced a turnover and Northwestern
worked the clock. Center Shanta Burks took a quick pass from Wills
and scored the final points from under the basket.
Following the game, Zoll was
quick to praise his assistant coach, Tony Holliday, for the success
of the team.
"This
young man really dedicated himself with these girls and gave them
the knowledge and discipline they needed to succeed." n
NEW LAW BARS DISTRIBUTION OF
PERFORMANCE-ENHANCING
SUPPLEMENTS IN SCHOOLS
Michigan public school employees
and volunteers are prohibited from promoting or supplying dietary
supplements with claims of enhanced athletic performance as a
result of a bill signed into law Nov. 23, 1999.
The new law ­ designated
Public Act 187 on Nov. 30, 1999 ­ covers androstendione and
creatine and any compounds labeled as performance-enhancing.
While the substances
are legal and may still be obtained by students through their
parents, the new law should help protect schools from the ethical,
health and liability issues that may evolve as the long-term effects
on adolescents become known. It may provide an early wake-up call
to students, parents and others that the health effects of these
substances are unknown, especially as they might affect growing
boys and girls.
The
legislation was sponsored in the Senate by Leon Stille of Spring
Lake, in the House by David Mead of Frankfort.
PUBLIC ACT 187
An act to amend 1976 PA 451,
entitled "An act to provide a system of public instruction
and elementary and secondary schools; to revise, consolidate,
and clarify the laws relating to elementary and secondary education;
to provide for the organization, regulation and maintenance of
schools, school districts, public school academies and intermediate
school districts; to prescribe rights, powers, duties and privileges
of schools, school district, public school academies and intermediate
school districts; to provide for the regulation of school teachers
and certain other school employees; to provide for school elections
and to prescribe powers and duties with respect thereto; to provide
for the levy and collection of taxes; to provide for the borrowing
of money and issuance of bonds and other evidences of indebtedness;
to establish a fund and provide for expenditures from that fund;
to provide for and prescribe the powers and duties of certain
state departments, the state board of education and certain other
boards and officials; to provide for licensure of boarding schools;
to prescribe penalties; and to repeal acts and parts of acts,"
(MCL 380.1 to 880.1852) to adding section 1317.
The People of the State of Michigan
enact:
Sec. 1317 (1)
Except as otherwise provided in subsection (2), a public school
employee or volunteer shall not do any of the following:
(a)
Knowingly sell, market, distribute or promote the use of a dietary
supplement that contains a performance-enhancing compound to a
pupil with whom the public school employee or volunteer has contact
as part of his or her duties as a public school employee or activities
as a public school volunteer.
(b) Knowingly endorse or suggest
the ingestion, intranasal application or inhalation of a dietary
supplement that contains a performance-enhancing compound by a
pupil with whom the public school employee or volunteer has contact
as part of his or her duties as a public school employee or activities
as a public school volunteer.
(2) This section does not prohibit
a public school employee or volunteer from doing any of the following:
(a)
Providing, endorsing or promoting the use of a dietary supplement
that contains a performance-enhancing compound to, or suggesting
the ingestion, intranasal application or inhalation of a dietary
supplement that contains a performance-enhancing compound by,
the public school employee's or volunteer's own child.
(b)
Selling, marketing, distributing or promoting the use of a dietary
supplement that contains a performance-enhancing compound to,
or endorsing or suggesting the ingestion, intranasal application
or inhalation of a dietary supplement that contains a performance-enhancing
compound by, a pupil as part of an activity that meets all of
the following:
(i)
Does not occur on school property or at a school-related function.
(ii)
Is entirely separate from any aspect of the public school employee's
employment as a public school employee or public school volunteer's
activities as a public school volunteer.
(iii) Does not in any way involve
information about or contacts with a pupil that the public school
employee or volunteer has had direct or indirect access to through
any aspect of the public school employee's employment as a public
school employee or public school volunteer's activities as a public
school volunteer.
(3)
A person who violates this section is subject to the penalties
under section 1804.
(4)
As used in this section:
(a)
"Dietary supplement" means that term as defined in section
201 of the federal food, drug and cosmetic act, chapter 675, 52
Stat. 1040, 21 U.S.C. 321.
(b)
"Performance-enhancing compound" means a manufactured
product for oral ingestion, intranasal application or inhalation
that meets both of the following:
(i) Contains a stimulant, amino
acid, hormone precursor, herb or other botanical, or any other
substance that is not an essential vitamin or mineral.
(ii)
Is intended to increase athletic or intellectual performance,
promote muscle growth, or increase an individual's endurance or
capacity for exercise.
(c)
"Public school employee" means a person employed by
a school district, local act school district, intermediate school
district or public school academy. For the purposes of this section,
public school employee also includes a person performing services
on behalf of a school district, local act school district, intermediate
school district or public school academy pursuant to a contract.
(d)
"Public school volunteer" means a person serving as
a volunteer in any capacity in a public school.
Enacting section 1. This amendatory
act takes effect 90 days after the date this amendatory act is
enacted.
This
act is ordered to take immediate effect. n
INTERNET MARKETERS OF DIETARY SUPPLEMENT
MUST PLACE SAFETY WARNINGS ON ANDROGEN SUPPLEMENT LABELING AND ADVERTISING
The Federal
Trade Commission on Nov. 16, 1999, settled charges against MET-Rx
USA, Inc. and AST Nutritional Concepts involving unsupported safety
claims made in the marketing of purported body-building supplements
that contain androstenedione ("androgen"), and other
steroid hormones, and in some cases, stimulants such as ephedra
and caffeine. The two marketers of androgen supplements must disclose
the potential risks of the supplements in all advertising, labeling
and promotional materials that make efficacy, performance, or
safety claims, as part of a settlement with the FTC. In separate
complaints, the FTC alleges that the two companies advertise that
their androgen supplements will increase strength and muscle mass
"safely and with minimal or no negative side effects."
The complaints challenge the companies' lack of substantiation
for their claims about the safety or lack of side effects of the
products. The claims were made primarily on Internet sites promoting
the products.
Androgens
are steroid hormones that are produced naturally in the body and
can be synthesized from natural and artificial sources. The companies'
androgen products contain various combinations of the steroid
hormones androstenedione, androstenediol, norandrostenedione,
and/or norandrostenediol. These substances convert in the body
to testosterone, estrogen, and/or other potent hormones, and thus
could pose safety risks and unwanted side effects similar to those
of more potent hormones. The disclosure required by the FTC warns
that these potential risks include unwanted changes in male and
female sexual characteristics, and special dangers to persons
at increased risk for prostate or breast cancer.
"Teenagers and athletes
who are using these supplements as performance or muscle enhancers
are being misled about their safety and potential negative side
effects. Not any more," said Jodie Bernstein, Director of
the FTC's Bureau of Consumer Protection. "Now, the labels
and ads for these products will give consumers the straight story
about the side effects and they'll be able to base their buying
decisions on the facts. This information is especially important
for teenagers, whose health may be threatened by long-term use
of steroid hormones."
"Parents,
coaches and athletes need to be aware of the real risks these
substances pose to the lives and health of young people and athletes
at all levels," said General Barry McCaffrey, Director of
the Office of National Drug Control Policy. "Today's action
by the FTC will help raise awareness of these risks. No victory
is worth the physical harms these substances can bring. It is
vital that we create a level playing field for competition where
athletes no longer feel that they need to chemically engineer
their bodies to compete and win. Today's action by the FTC is
an important part of a larger federal effort to deal with the
use of drugs in sport. We applaud the FTC for its leadership."
Robert F. Kanaby,
Executive Director of the National Federation of State High School
Associations, stated that: "I support the FTC's actions to
inform consumers about the risks of performance-enhancing supplements.
We want student athletes to participate in athletics without the
dubious aid of substances that may be harmful to their long-term
well being." The Federation represents high school athletic
and activity associations across the nation.
The FTC's complaints name AST
Nutritional Concepts & Research, Inc. (AST), based in Colorado,
and its president Paul Delia; and MET-Rx USA, Inc. and its subsidiary,
MET-Rx Substrate Technology, Inc. (MET-Rx), based in Irvine, California.
The complaints allege that the defendants claimed their androgen
supplements, taken in recommended doses, are safe, produce no
or minimal negative side effects, and do not pose health or safety
risks. The FTC alleges that the defendants lacked scientific evidence
to support those claims. In addition, the complaint against AST
alleges that the company falsely claimed that its androgen supplements
do not contain steroid hormones.
The
proposed settlements would prohibit the defendants from making
claims about the absolute safety or side effects for any food,
dietary supplement or drug, including androgen products, unless
they have competent and reliable scientific evidence to substantiate
those claims. In addition, the proposed AST settlement prohibits
the company from representing that any androgen product does not
contain steroids or steroid hormones.
The proposed orders would require
the following labeling and advertising disclosure for any androgen
supplement for which any efficacy, performance, or safety claim
is made:
WARNING: This product contains steroid
hormones that may cause breast enlargement, testicle shrinkage,
and infertility in males, and increased facial and body hair,
voice deepening, and clitoral enlargement in females. Higher doses
may increase these risks. If you are at risk for prostate or
breast cancer you should not use this product.
The proposed
orders also would require the following labeling and advertising
disclosure for any androgen supplement containing ephedra (also
known as ephedrine):
WARNING: This product contains ephedra.
Taking more than the recommended serving may result in heart attack,
stroke, seizure or death. Consult a health care practitioner prior
to use if you have high blood pressure, heart or thyroid disease,
diabetes, difficulty urinating, prostate enlargement, or glaucoma,
or are using any prescription drug. Do not use if you are taking
a MAO inhibitor or any allergy, asthma, or cold medication containing
ephedrine, pseudoephedrine, or phenylpropanolamine. Discontinue
use if dizziness, sleeplessness, loss of appetite, or nausea occurs.
n
AND ANDROSTENEDIONE
NFHS On Creatine
In response to the recent focus
on the use of food supplements, specifically creatine, the NFHS
Sports Medicine Advisory Committee in August 1998 issued a position
statement on the use of drugs, medicine and food supplements in
interscholastic sports. Text of the committee's statement follows:
"School
personnel and coaches should not dispense any drug, medication
or food supplement except with extreme caution and in accordance
with policies developed in consultation with parents, health-care
professionals and senior administrative personnel of the school
or school district.
"Use
of any drug, medication or food supplement in a way not prescribed
by the manufacturer should not be authorized or encouraged by
school personnel and coaches. Even natural substances in unnatural
amounts may have short-term or long-term negative health effects.
In order to
minimize health and safety risks to student-athletes, maintain
ethical standards and reduce liability risks, school personnel
and coaches should never supply, recommend or permit the use of
any drug, medication or food supplement solely for performance-enhancing
purposes."
Jerry
Diehl, assistant director of the NFHS and staff liaison to the
Sports Medicine Advisory Committee, said the committee issued
this statement in response to requests from member state high
school associations to address the increased use of food supplements
such as creatine.
The
Sports Medicine Advisory Committee is composed of four state association
representatives and six members of the medical community, and
is chaired by Don Herrmann of the Wisconsin Interscholastic Athletic
Association. n
NFHS On Androstenedione
In light of publicity about
the use of androstenedione by Mark McGwire of the St. Louis Cardinals,
the National Federation of State High School Associations in August
1998 reiterated its stance against the use of any drug, medication
or food supplement by high school athletes solely for performance-enhancing
purposes.
"In
recent days, the Associated Press has quoted Mark McGwire as speaking
favorably of androstenedione and creatine," said Robert E
Kanaby, NFHS executive director. "We do not presume to second-guess
Mr. McGwire's statements about what may be appropriate for a professional
athlete in his 30s; however, drugs are not harmless and are not
free of consequences when ingested by student-athletes of high
school age."
On
Aug. 14 after much discussion about the use of the food supplement,
creatine, the NFHS Sports Medicine Advisory Committee issued a
position statement on the use of drugs, medicine and food supplements
in interscholastic sports. Kanaby said that androstenedione, an
anabolic agent which is a metabolic precursor to testosterone,
would be covered, along with creatine and any other drug, medicine
or food supplement, in the committee's statement. Text of the
committee's statement follows:
"School
personnel and coaches should not dispense any drug, medication
or food supplement except with extreme caution and in accordance
with policies developed in consultation with parents, health-care
professionals and senior administrative personnel of the school
or school district.
"Use
of any drug, medication or food supplement in a way not prescribed
by the manufacturer should not be authorized or encouraged by
school personnel and coaches. Even natural substances in unnatural
amounts may have short-term or long-term negative health effects.
"In order
to minimize health and safety risks to student-athletes, maintain
ethical standards and reduce liability risks, school personnel
and coaches should never supply ' recommend or permit the use
of any drug, medication or food supplement solely for performance-enhancing
purposes."
"I
strongly urge that high school student-athletes, parents, coaches
and school administrators thoroughly investigate short-term and
long-term health consequences before ingesting, or allowing the
ingestion of, any performance-enhancing substance," Kanaby
said. n
ATTENDANCE RECORDS FALL IN FOOTBALL & GIRLS BASKETBALL
FOOTBALL
-- The combination
of great November weekend weather and a new five-week playoff
format produced large crowds throughout the state and resulted
in record attendance for most levels of the Football Playoffs.
Although final figures have not been confirmed, preliminary accounting
indicates that over 560,000 fans attended high school football
games throughout the state over the five weeks, including the
Finals held at the Silverdome on Nov. 26-27.
The new playoff format enacted
this year doubled the entry teams to 256 and resulted in 128 additional
games in a newly created Pre-District round.
1999 FOOTBALL ATTENDANCE AND
PREVIOUS RECORDS
|
Pre-District |
District |
Regional |
Semifinal |
Final |
|
1999 Attendance |
215,000 |
156,519* |
86,571* |
39,000 |
67,000 |
|
Previous/Current Record |
---- |
115,514 |
78,157 |
40,819 |
71,156 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
(1990) |
(1994) |
(1992) |
(1995) |
*New
Record
Total
Football Attendance
1999 564,090* (five-week playoff)
Previous Record
287,252 (1994 - four week playoff)
The Pre-District
revenue sharing plan allowed each competing school 33 percent
of the net revenue from 128 games. 256 teams were compensated
from a pool of $453,524 returned to schools by the MHSAA for games
played Oct. 29-30. Schools were guaranteed a minimum payout of
$300; however, minimum amounts were necessary at only four sites.
The top payout was $5,862 each to St. Joseph and Stevensville
Lakeshore high schools for their Pre-District game at St. Joseph.
GIRLS BASKETBALL -- The Girls Basketball Finals
set an attendance record for the second time in the three years
that the event has been in Mt. Pleasant, at Central Michigan University's
Rose Arena. The Finals on Dec. 4 drew a record 10,958 fans, and
the three-day total of 21,606 eclipsed the previous mark set in
1997, the first year CMU hosted the event.
1999 GIRLS BASKETBALL ATTENDANCE
AND PREVIOUS RECORDS
|
Semifinal |
Final |
3-Day Total |
|
1999 Attendance |
10,648 |
10,958* |
21,606* |
|
Previous/Current Record |
11,030 |
9,963 |
20,993 |
|
|
(1997) |
(1997) |
(1997) |
RUSTER FOUNDATION PLAYS LARGE ROLE IN
PROMOTING
SPORTSMANSHIP
The
Ruster Foundation continues to be a very positive force in promoting
good sportsmanship. Thus far during the 1999-00 school year, more
than 3,000 student-athletes and other student leaders have had
the opportunity to attend one of the 42 workshops provided for
conferences, leagues and individual schools.
The emphasis of the workshops
is to enhance leadership skills of the participants, to determine
successful sportsmanship strategies, to isolate barriers to sportsmanship,
and to develop action plans for "Good Sportsmanship."
Founded in 1983,
the Ruster Foundation and Ruster Student Services was originally
established to make students and communities aware of chemical
-use prevention, but it has since expanded into leadership and
sportsmanship seminars.
A
listing of the workshops conducted by the Ruster Foundation, through
its division, Ruster Student Services, from August 1999 through
December 1999 follows:
|
Conference or School |
Workshops |
Schools |
Students |
Adults |
|
Big "9" Conference |
2 |
9 |
148 |
|
|
Big North Conference |
1 |
8 |
79 |
|
|
Burton Public Schools |
1 |
3 |
89 |
|
|
Capitol Area Conference |
1 |
8 |
57 |
|
|
Farmington Public Schools |
1 |
3 |
87 |
|
|
Frankenmuth High School |
1 |
1 |
93 |
|
|
Fruitport High School |
1 |
1 |
65 |
|
|
Genesee High School |
1 |
1 |
64 |
|
|
Greenville High School |
1 |
1 |
93 |
|
|
Highland Conference |
1 |
6 |
|
43 |
|
Highland Conference |
2 |
6 |
84 |
|
|
Ingham County League |
1 |
7 |
87 |
|
|
Jack Pine Conference |
1 |
8 |
104 |
|
|
Lake Michigan Conference |
1 |
7 |
83 |
|
|
Lakeland Conference |
1 |
9 |
93 |
|
|
Macomb Area Conference |
1 |
29 |
|
114 |
|
Macomb Area Conference |
5 |
35 |
294 |
|
|
Mid-Michigan Athletic
Conference |
1 |
10 |
93 |
|
|
O.K. Conference (Red Division) |
1 |