BULLETIN
November 2000 Volume LXXVII Number 3
OFFICIAL REPORT OF BOARD OF CANVASSERS
East Lansing,
Sept. 15, 2000
We,
whose signatures appear below, declare the following to be nominees
for, or members elect of, the Representative Council or the Upper
Peninsula Athletic Committee of the Michigan High School Athletic
Association, Inc., as a result of ballots received in accordance
with the provisions of Article IV, Section 6, of the Constitution,
or as authorized by the Upper Peninsula Athletic Committee at
its meeting on Oct.3, 1941.
REPRESENTATIVE COUNCIL
NORTHERN SECTION -
CLASS A AND B SCHOOLS (#1)
Total number
of legal ballots received 41
Robert
Riemersma, Manistee 41
Illegal
or incomplete ballots received 2
Elected
by majority of votes--
Robert
Riemersma
SOUTHWESTERN SECTION -
CLASS A AND B SCHOOLS (#2)
Total number
of legal ballots 46
Michael
S. Shibler, Rockford 46
Illegal
or incomplete ballots received 2
Elected
by majority of votes--
Michael
S. Shibler
SOUTHEASTERN SECTION -
CLASS A AND B SCHOOLS (#3)
Total number
of legal ballots received 73
Eric
C. Federico, Gibraltar 73
Illegal
or incomplete ballots received 8
Elected
by majority of vote--
Eric
C. Federico
UPPER PENINSULA -
CLASS C AND D SCHOOLS (#4)
Total number
of legal ballots received 31
Keith
Alto, Newberry 31
Illegal
or incomplete ballots received 3
Elected
by majority of votes--Keith Alto
NORTHERN SECTION -
CLASS C AND D SCHOOLS (#5)
Total number
of legal ballots received 56
William
D. Newkirk, Sanford 56
Illegal
or incomplete ballots received 3
Elected
by majority of vote--
William
D. Newkirk
STATEWIDE AT-LARGE (#6)
Total number
of legal ballots received 493
Scott
Grimes, Grand Haven 119
James
Hilgendorf, Johannesburg 59
Dennis
F. Kniola, Stevensville 103
William
S. McLemore Jr., Burton 18
Paul
N. Price, Republic 45
Peter
Ryan, Saginaw 114
Brian
Zdanowski, Greenville 35
Illegal
or incomplete ballots received 20
No
majority--Names of Scott Grimes and Peter Ryan submitted to schools
JUNIOR HIGH/MIDDLE SCHOOLS (#7)
Total number
of legal ballots received 167
Keith
Eldred, Williamston 91
Bart
Estola, Shelby 41
Barry
Hobrla, Lowell 35
Illegal
or incomplete ballots received 12
Elected
by majority of votes--Keith Eldred
PRIVATE AND PAROCHIAL
HIGH SCHOOLS (#8)
Total number
of legal ballots received 55
Tom
Rashid, Detroit 55
Illegal
or incomplete ballots received 5
Elected
by majority of votes--Tom Rashid
UPPER PENINSULA
ATHLETIC COMMITTEE
ATHLETIC COACH (#9)
Total number
of legal ballots received 36
John
Croze, Calumet 7
Brad
Grayvold, Norway 3
Doug
Ingalls, St. Ignace 6
Greg
Jeske, Menominee 0
Mark
Marana, Negaunee 4
Jim
Martin, Sautl Ste. Marie 0
Richard
Mettlach, Gwinn 1
George
R. Peterson III, Watersmeet 3
Paul
Polfus, Carney 8
Gerald
S. Racine, Ishpeming 4
Illegal
or incomplete ballots received 1
No
Majority--Names of Paul Polfus and John Croze submitted to schools
CLASS D SCHOOLS (#10)
Total number
of legal ballots received 16
Paul
N. Price, Republic 6
Joe
Reddinger, Iron Mountain 10
Illegal
or incomplete ballots received 1
Elected
by majority of votes--
Joe
Reddinger
BOARD OF CANVASSERS (Signed)
Ron Beegle, Athletic Director,
Charlotte HS
Rudy
Godefroidt, Principal, Hemlock HS
Bill
McBeth, Principal, Buchanan HS
Therese
Peterson, Superintendent,
Webberville
Community Schools
Member
Absent:
Tom
Tweedy, Principal, Okemos-Chippewa Middle School
OFFICIAL REPORT
OF SECOND MEETING OF BOARD OF CANVASSERS East Lansing, Oct. 4, 2000
We, whose
signatures appear below, declare the following to be nominees
for, or members elect of, the Representative Council or the Upper
Peninsula Athletic Committee of the Michigan High School Athletic
Association, Inc., as a result of ballots received in accordance
with the provisions of Article IV, Section 6, of the Constitution,
or as authorized by the Upper Peninsula Athletic Committee at
its meeting on Oct.3, 1941.
REPRESENTATIVE COUNCIL
STATEWIDE AT-LARGE
Total
number of legal ballots received 593
Scott
Grimes, Grand Haven 336
Peter
Ryan, Saginaw 257
Illegal
or incomplete ballots received 38
Elected
by majority of votes--
Scott
Grimes, Grand Haven
UPPER
PENINSULA
ATHLETIC
COMMITTEE
ATHLETIC COACH
Total number of legal ballots
received 34
John
Croze, Calumet 15
Paul
Polfus, Carney 19
Illegal
or incomplete ballots received 3
Elected
by majority of votes--
Paul
Polfus, Carney
(Signed)
Ron Beegle, Athletic Director,
Charlotte HS
EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
MEETING East Lansing, September 13, 2000
Executive Committee Authority
and Responsibility -
The Executive Committee was reminded of its authority under Article
VII of the MHSAA Constitution and specifically its responsibility
to consider each application for waiver of an eligibility requirement
on its individual merits, determining if the regulation serves
the purpose for which it was intended in each case or if the regulation
works an undue hardship on any student who is the subject of a
request for waiver. (These underlying criteria may not be restated
for every subject of these minutes.)
The Executive Committee was
reminded that it was the responsibility of each member school
involved to provide sufficient factual information about the specific
request for the Executive Committee to reach a decision without
further investigation. If information is incomplete, contradictory
or otherwise unclear or has been received too late to be studied
completely, the Executive Committee may deny the request for waiver
or delay action. Such requests may be resubmitted to the Executive
Committee with additional information at a subsequent meeting
or appealed to the full Representative Council.
A determination of undue hardship
is a matter addressed to the discretion of the Executive Committee
within the educational philosophy and secondary role of voluntary
extracurricular competitive athletics in the academic environment.
The Executive Committee was cautioned to avoid making exceptions
that would create precedent that effectively changes a rule without
Representative Council action or local board of education adoption,
which would exceed Executive Committee authority.
Students for whom waiver of
a particular regulation is granted must be eligible in all respects
under all other sections and interpretations of the regulations
prior to their participation.
Consistent with rulings of the
Attorney General and Michigan Supreme Court, schools are not bound
by the decisions of the Executive Committee, but the Association
may limit participation in the post-season tournaments it sponsors
to those schools which apply rules and penalties as promulgated
by the MHSAA and adopted by each member school's board of education.
The MHSAA exercises no independent authority over schools or students
during regular season.
Traverse
City Christian High School (Regulation I, Section 1[D]) - Request was made to waive the
enrollment regulation so that this school, which exceeds 99 students
in grades 9 through 12 (115 by last February's count to the MHSAA,
109 by current count), may utilize 8th-grade students in its high
school soccer and golf programs.
The Executive Committee noted
that the 99 student limit was recently established by the Representative
Council and that it would exceed the Executive Committee's authority
to waive that limit. The request for waiver was denied.
Brighton,
Howell and Pinckney High Schools (Regulation I, Section 1[F])
- The Executive
Committee approved the addition of Pinckney High School to the
cooperative agreement in girls gymnastics that has existed between
the other two schools since 1998. Brighton will be the primary
school. Combined enrollment will be 5,601.
Burton-Bentley, Burton-Atherton
and Genesee High Schools (Regulation I, Section 1[E]) - The Executive Committee tabled
the application for a cooperative program in wrestling because
no league resolution was provided. Only Bentley High School has
sponsored the sport previously and it would be the primary school.
The combined enrollment would be 902 for MHSAA tournament classification
purposes (moves a Division 4 program to Division 2).
Holly and Oxford High Schools
(Regulation I, Section 1[F]) -
The Executive Committee approved a cooperative agreement in boys
and girls skiing. Holly has sponsored the sport previously and
will be the primary school. The combined enrollment will be 2,399
(Class A) for MHSAA tournament purposes.
Lansing-Catholic Central and
Lansing Christian High Schools (Regulation I, Section 1[E]) - The Executive Committee approved
a cooperative program in ice hockey for Catholic Central, which
has sponsored the sport previously, and Lansing Christian, which
has not. The combined enrollment for MHSAA tournament purposes
will be 724 (Division 3). Catholic Central will be the primary
school.
Livonia
Public Schools (Regulation I, Section 1[F]) - The Executive Committee approved
a cooperative program in girls gymnastics between Livonia-Churchill,
Franklin and Stevenson High Schools, whose combined enrollment
will be 5,709. None of the schools sponsored the sport previously.
Churchill will be the primary school.
Manistee and Manistee-Catholic
Central High Schools (Regulation I, Section 1[E] & Regulation
III, Section 1 -
The Executive Committee approved a cooperative program in wrestling
at both the high school and junior high/middle school levels.
Manistee has sponsored the sport previously and will be the primary
school for a program whose enrollment for MHSAA tournament classification
purposes will be 650 (remaining Division 3).
Mattawan and Kalamazoo-Hackett
Catholic Central High Schools (Regulation I, Section 1[F]) - The Executive Committee approved
a cooperative program in boys swimming and diving. Only Hackett
has sponsored the sport previously (Class B-C-D), but Mattawan
will be the primary school for a program that has a combined enrollment
of 1,465 for MHSAA tournament classification purposes (Class A).
Waterford
Kettering, Waterford Mott and Auburn Hills-Avondale High Schools
(Regulation I, Section 1[F]) -
The Executive Committee approved a cooperative program in boys
and girls skiing between these schools. Kettering and Mott have
sponsored the sports previously, although Mott has not had a girls
team in five years and Kettering did not have enough girls at
the end of last season to enter the MHSAA tournament. The combined
enrollment of the three schools is 3,979 for MHSAA tournament
purposes (two Class A programs become one).
Wayland Union and Byron Center
High Schools (Regulation I, Section 1[F]) -
The Executive Committee approved a cooperative program in ice
hockey. Wayland Union has sponsored the sport previously and will
be the primary school. Combined enrollment for MHSAA tournament
purposes will be 1,602 (moving the program from Division 3 to
Division 1).
Traverse
City West High School (Regulation I, Sections 1, 7 & 9) - Requests to waive the enrollment,
previous semester record and transfer sections of the eligibility
regulation were made on behalf of a student who participated in
9th-grade soccer for Traverse City West High School in the fall
of the 1999-00 school year although he was only enrolled in one
class at that school. This was only discovered when the student
was trying out for the junior varsity team this fall.
The Executive Committee confirmed
that all contests in which this student participated during the
1999-00 school year must be forfeited by the school and the committee
granted the student eligibility following completion of the first
half of the scheduled junior varsity boys soccer contests of the
2000 season.
Inkster
High School (Regulation I, Sections 4, 5 & 9) - Late requests to waive several
sections of the eligibility regulation were made on behalf of
a student who began 9th grade in the fall of 1996 and has been
enrolled in several schools and home schooled for four school
years, most recently attending Redford-Bishop Borgess High School.
The reason given for submitting this request was that the student
was ineligible last year.
The
Executive Committee denied the requests for waiver.
Gibraltar-Carlson High School
(Regulation I, Section 7) -
Request was made to waive the previous semester record regulation
on behalf of a 7th semester student who failed courses during
the second semester of the 1999-00 school year. He was hospitalized,
attempted to return to school, but could not overcome accumulated
absences.
The
Executive Committee granted the request for waiver.
Kalkaska High School (Regulation
I, Section 7) -
Request to waive the previous semester record regulation was made
on behalf of an 11th-grade student who had been an excellent student
until December 1999 when she moved to live with her father in
Phoenix where she began to have emotional problems now diagnosed
as depression. The student returned to live with her mother and
her husband. She passed only three courses during the second semester
of 1999-00.
The
Executive Committee granted the request for waiver, noting the
student is not eligible until an Educational Transfer Form is
received.
Linden
High School (Regulation I, Sections 7 & 9) - Requests to waive the previous
semester and transfer sections of the eligibility regulation were
made on behalf of a 12th-grade student who began 1999-00 at New
Lothrop High School but ceased attending on Sept. 29 because of
emotional strain that followed the death of his girlfriend in
an auto accident. In the spring, he attended Chesaning High School
for a week, withdrawing because he was behind academically and
claimed harassment by students. He has relocated to his sister-in-law's
residence in the Linden Community School District.
Noting the multiplicity of residences
and schools and citing the lack of documentation that supported
the need for the current residence and school, the Executive Committee
denied the requests for waiver.
Allen Park-Cabrini High School
(Regulation I, Section 9) -
Request to waive the transfer regulation was made on behalf of
a 12th-grade student who attended Catholic grade schools in the
downriver Detroit area for eight years and Southgate-Aquinas High
School (now closed) for 9th grade. The student's father died in
1995. The student moved with his siblings and mother to Linden.
His mother died in November 1999. He remained in his Linden home
as two aunts shared in the care of him and his siblings. In February,
one of the aunts moved to the Linden residence while commuting
to her job in Detroit. The Linden residence has been sold. The
student's siblings live with one aunt, where 11 people reside;
he lives with the other aunt who is married but has no children,
and he attends the closest nonpublic school, which is Cabrini
where most of his friends from Aquinas enrolled after Aquinas
closed.
The
Executive Committee granted the request for waiver.
Ann Arbor-Huron High School
(Regulation I, Section 9 ) - Request
to waive the transfer regulation was made on behalf of a 10th-grade
student who relocated with her mother from New Jersey. Her father's
last day of work in New Jersey is Sept. 29, when he too will move
to Ann Arbor where they have purchased and occupy a home. Their
home in New Jersey is nearly vacant and will be entirely vacant
when the father relocates.
The
Executive Committee granted the request for waiver.
Atlanta High School (Regulation
I, Section 9[D]) -
Request was made to waive the transfer regulation on behalf of
a student who attended Atlanta High School for junior high school,
9th grade and two trimesters of 10th grade. Because of attendance
problems in one class, the student transferred to Hillman High
School on Feb. 25, 2000. He reenrolled this fall at Atlanta, which
requested eligibility after 90 school days since Feb. 25.
Noting
that the student had eligibility this fall at Hillman and finding
no compelling reason to make a third school change, the Executive
Committee denied the request for waiver.
Berkley High School (Regulation
I, Section 9) -
Request to waive the transfer regulation was made on behalf of
an 11th-grade student who last year attended military school in
Georgia while living with his mother. He moved to the Berkley
School District residence of his father, who was never married
to his mother. An otherwise completed Educational Transfer Form
and birth records identifying these as the biological parents
were provided.
The
Executive Committee granted the request for waiver.
Bloomfield Hills-Academy of
the Sacred Heart (Regulation I, Section 9) -
Request was made to waive the transfer regulation on behalf of
a 10th-grade student who attended Catholic schools through 8th
grade and Bloomfield Hills-Lahser High School for 9th grade. She
was a witness to criminal activity associated with that school.
She has changed schools without changing residence, and Cranbrook-Kingswood
High School is closer than Sacred Heart to the student's residence.
Given
the need for change and the history of Catholic school attendance,
the Executive Committee granted the request to waive two aspects
of the transfer regulation.
Bloomfield Hills-Andover High
School (Regulation I, Section 9) -
Request to waive the transfer regulation was made on behalf of
an 11th-grade student who qualified for advance placement courses
at Andover High School which were not available to her at Bloomfield
Hills-Marian High School.
The
athletic director, student and her mother addressed the Executive
Committee, explaining the sequence of events and counsel that
delayed from last semester to this the student's enrollment at
Andover High School.
The
Executive Committee denied the request for waiver, noting that
it cannot be put in the position of making decisions by comparing
member schools' curricula, grading systems and demographics.
Bridgeport
High School (Regulation I, Section 9) -
Request to waive the transfer regulation was made on behalf of
a 12th-grade student who is a Frankenmuth resident who spent his
9th-grade year at Saginaw-Nouvel Catholic Central and 10th grade
at Frankenmuth High School until May of 1999 when he was expelled
for 180 days. During that time, he was tutored by a teacher from
the Bridgeport district. This August, he was denied reenrollment
at Nouvel and then enrolled Aug. 22 at Bridgeport.
The Executive Committee determined
that if during both semesters of 1999-00, the student was on the
rolls in a designated alternative education program of the Bridgeport-Spalding
School District while completing the PASS curriculum, then the
student is eligible under the transfer regulation. Otherwise,
the request to waive the transfer regulation is denied.
Canton-Plymouth
Canton High School (Regulation I, Section 9 or 9[B]) - Request to waive the transfer
regulation was made on behalf of an 11th-grade student who attended
Ann Arbor-Gabriel Richard High School as a 9th-grader where he
competed in cross country. He attended 10th grade at Ann Arbor
Academy, where no sports teams are sponsored.
Noting the student has attended
three schools and citing the lack of documentation that supported
the need to attend the current school, the Executive Committee
denied the request for waiver.
Carson City-Crystal High School
(Regulation I, Section 9[B]) -
Request to waive the transfer regulation to permit eligibility
only at the subvarsity level during the first semester of the
2000-01 school year was made on behalf of a 10th-grade student
who had previously been home-schooled without interscholastic
athletic participation.
The
Executive Committee granted the request for waiver at the subvarsity
level only during the first semester of the 2000-01 school year.
Charlevoix
High School (Regulation I, Section 9) -
Request to waive the transfer regulation was made on behalf of
a 12th-grade student who relocated from his parents in Oregon
to the residence of his grandparents in Charlevoix in order to
escape a declining academic environment in Oregon, to live with
his grandfather for whom he worked during the summer, to become
reacquainted with his Michigan relatives, and to take advantage
of Michigan's winter sporting events.
The Executive Committee denied
the request for waiver.
Charlotte High School (Regulation
I, Section 9) -
Request to waive the transfer regulation was made on behalf of
a 10th-grade student who began 9th grade at Charlotte High School
where she competed in cross country, and she enrolled at Potterville
High School during the second semester. There was not a change
of residence. At its Aug. 16, 2000 meeting, the Executive Committee
denied the request for waiver. The matter was resubmitted with
additional information.
The
Executive Committee noted that there is a poorly documented case
for the need to transfer out of Charlotte and no case presented
for returning to Charlotte High School; and the request for waiver
was denied.
Dansville
High School (Regulation I, Section 9) - Request
to waive the transfer regulation was made on behalf of an 11th-grade
student whose parents are divorced and who moved with his father
from Georgia to the residence of the student's grandmother in
Dansville. The father has disposed of his Georgia residence but
will be in Georgia periodically to sell his business.
The request for waiver was granted
by the Executive Committee.
Dansville High School (Regulation
I, Section 9) -
Request to waive the transfer regulation was made on behalf of
an 11th-grade student who previously attended Holt-St. Matthew
Lutheran School where he competed in soccer last fall.
The
Executive Committee denied the request for waiver.
Dearborn-Divine Child High School
(Regulation I, Section 9) -
Request to waive the transfer regulation was made on behalf of
a 10th-grade student who transferred from Benton Hall Academy
in Nashville, TN, relocating with his parents in Canton. All but
the student's 9th-grade education was in Catholic schools, the
closest of which is Divine Child, although there is a closer nonpublic
school of a different denomination.
The Executive Committee granted
the request for waiver.
Deerfield
High School (Regulation I, Section 9[C]) -
Request to waive the transfer regulation to permit immediate eligibility
in golf was made on behalf of a student who transferred from Britton-Macon,
which participates in a cooperative program in golf with Deerfield.
The
Executive Committee granted the request for golf only during the
first semester of the 2000-01 school year.
Detroit-Holy Redeemer High School
(Regulation I, Section 9[B]) -
Request to waive the transfer regulation to permit eligibility
only at the subvarsity level during the first semester of the
2000-01 school year was made on behalf of a 10th-grade student
who last year attended Detroit-Western High school where he did
not compete in any sports.
The
Executive Committee granted the request for waiver at the subvarsity
level only during the first semester of the 2000-01 school year.
Detroit-St.
Martin de Porres High School (Regulation I, Section 9[B]) - Request to waive the transfer
regulation to permit eligibility only at the subvarsity level
during the first semester of the 2000-01 school year was made
on behalf of a 10th-grade student who last year attended Detroit-Renaissance
High School where she did not participate in any interscholastic
sports.
The
Executive Committee granted the request for waiver at the subvarsity
level only during the first semester of the 2000-01 school year.
East
Grand Rapids High School (Regulation I, Section 9) - Request to waive the transfer
regulation was made on behalf of an 11th-grade student of abusive
parents who divorced in 1993. The student lived with his mother
until, at age 13, he was kicked out of her house. He moved to
his father's residence and began 9th grade at Plymouth Canton
High School. He was generally neglected by his alcoholic father.
The student relocated to the residence of his sister in Knoxville,
but her boyfriend became abusive to them both. He then relocated
to his brother and his wife in East Grand Rapids.
The Executive Committee granted
the request for waiver.
Ferndale
High School (Regulation I, Section 9) -
Request to waive the transfer regulation was made on behalf of
a 10th-grade student whose father is a very recent administrative
hire of the Ferndale School District. He resided in a Residence
Inn in Southfield while seeking permanent housing. The student
and his mother remained in Ohio pending a determination of eligibility.
At its Aug. 16, 2000 meeting, the Executive Committee determined
that, inasmuch as the student was not enrolled in the requesting
school and there was no information that would provide certainty
that the student and his parents would reside in Ferndale during
the current season if at all, the request for waiver should be
denied.
The
school resubmitted the request for waiver for this student, who
has enrolled at Ferndale. The student's mother also has relocated.
On Oct. 1, the family is closing on the purchase of a home in
the Ferndale district that is not contingent on the sale of their
home in Ohio.
The
Executive Committee granted the request for waiver.
Flint-Kearsley High School (Regulation
I, Section 9[B]) -
A late request to waive the transfer regulation to permit eligibility
only at the subvarsity level during the first semester of the
2000-01 school year was made on behalf of a 9th-grade student
who attended Kearsley schools for 6th, 7th and 8th grades, enrolled
at Davison High school, but after one week of school and practicing
with the golf team, enrolled at Kearsley High School.
The Executive Committee noted
that the conditions of at least one practice met the definition
of a scrimmage. The Executive Committee determined it should not
override the specific requirements of Section 9(B), which have
been adopted by the Representative Council and member schools;
and the request for waiver was denied.
Freeland High School (Regulation
I, Section 9) -
Request was made to waive or interpret the transfer regulation
to allow immediate eligibility to a 12th-grade student who withdrew
from the day program at Freeland High School on Nov. 11, 1999,
and enrolled in the Bay-Arenac ISD adult education program so
that his classes could be scheduled around a job to help him support
a child. His permanent records remained with Freeland; and the
student, school and ISD had the expectation that his enrollment
at the ISD was short term with credits going toward graduation
at Freeland High School. He returned to a regular schedule at
Freeland High School this fall with no grades for the first semester
of 1999-00 but a satisfactory record for the second semester of
1999-00.
The
Executive Committee determined that the student is eligible under
the previous semester and transfer sections, and that this semester
and the next are his 7th and 8th, the last two for which he is
eligible.
Grand
Rapids-Catholic Central High School (Regulation I, Section 9)
- Request was
made to waive the transfer regulation on behalf of a student who
attended private schools in Chile and Brazil before enrolling
at Caledonia High School for 1999-00, but who wished to continue
the Catholic education to which he was accustomed in South America.
There has been no change of residence.
The Executive Committee denied
the request for waiver.
Grandville-Calvin
Christian High School (Regulation I, Section 9[B]) - Request to waive the transfer
regulation to permit eligibility only at the subvarsity level
during the first semester of the 2000-01 school year was made
on behalf of a 9th-grade student who attended Grandville High
School for three days. She did not participate in any sports at
Grandville.
The
Executive Committee granted the request for waiver only at the
subvarsity level during the first semester of the 2000-01 school
year.
Highland-Milford
High School (Regulation I, Section 9) -
A late request was made to waive the transfer regulation, Interpretation
No. 69, on behalf of a 9th-grade student who attended three days
of basketball practice at Farmington Hills-Mercy High School but
was cut from the team. In addition, the student's parents divorced
and her father refused to pay the tuition at Mercy.
The Executive Committee denied
the request for waiver.
Hudsonville-Freedom
Baptist High School (Regulation I, Section 9) - At its Aug. 16, 2000 meeting,
the Executive Committee tabled late requests to waive the transfer
regulation on behalf of:
1. a 10th-grade student who
last year attended Grand Rapids Baptist where he participated
in athletics. His father accepted a position at Freedom Baptist,
which requires enrollment of his children as a condition of employment.
The change of residence is not complete; they have engaged a builder
but cannot begin construction until their current home sells.
2.
10th and 11th-grade sisters whose family is in transition between
residences to get closer to their father's employment. The 10th-grader
played high school sports previously, the 11th-grader has not.
The
school resubmitted these items and an additional request for eligibility
only at the subvarsity level on behalf of a 10th-grade student
who last year attended Holland Christian where she did not participate
in high school sports.
The
Executive Committee did not find any substantially new or different
information for the two previously tabled requests, which were
denied. For the new matter, the Executive Committee granted the
request for waiver at the subvarsity level only during the first
semester of the 2000-01 school year.
Imlay City High School (Regulation
I, Section 9) -
Request to waive the transfer regulation was made on behalf of
a 10th-grade student who moved from her father's home in Florida
to her mother's home in Imlay City. Because the marriage in Mexico
at age 15 was not considered legal, there was no divorce decree.
An otherwise completed Educational Transfer Form was provided
with birth records that identified these as the biological parents.
The
Executive Committee granted the request for waiver.
Kalkaska High School (Regulation
I, Section 9) -
Request was made to waive or interpret the transfer regulation
to allow immediate eligibility at Kalkaska High School for an
11th-grade student who lived at home and attended Kalkaska High
School as a first semester 9th-grader, lived with friends in Traverse
City and attended Traverse City Central High School as a second
semester 9th-grader, lived at home in Kalkaska during the summer
of 1999, lived at home and commuted to Traverse City as a first
semester 10th-grader at Traverse City Central, lived with different
friends in Traverse City as a second semester 10th-grader at Traverse
City Central, and lived at home in Kalkaska during the summer
of 2000.
The
Executive Committee determined that the pattern of residence for
this student - (1) in Kalkaska commuting to Traverse City during
one semester; (2) with friends in Traverse City while visiting
Kalkaska frequently the next semester; (3) in Kalkaska during
the summer; in Kalkaska commuting to Traverse City during the
next semester; (4) with different friends in Traverse City while
visiting Kalkaska frequently the next semester; in Kalkaska during
the summer - is not sufficient to sustain that the student established
a residence away from his parents in Kalkaska and has returned
to live with his parents. Therefore, exception (2) of the transfer
regulation does not apply and the request for waiver was denied.
Lansing
Christian High School (Regulation I, Section 9) - A late request to waive the
transfer regulation, Interpretation No. 78, was made on behalf
of a student from Germany who was not part of any exchange program.
Citing
the express language of the Interpretation adopted by the Representative
Council and member schools, the Executive Committee denied the
request for waiver.
Lansing
Christian High School (Regulation I, Section 9) - A late request to waive the
transfer regulation, Interpretation No. 78, was made on behalf
of a 12th-grade student from Korea who attended Lansing Christian
last year as part of an approved foreign exchange program. She
sought to participate for two more semesters as she returned to
live with the same family as last year.
The Executive Committee denied
the request for waiver.
Leroy-Pine
River High School (Regulation I, Section 9) - A late request was made to
waive the transfer regulation on behalf of a 12th-grade student
who attended Pine River Area Schools from 3rd through 10th-grades.
As an 11th-grader, he attended Reed City Public Schools in order
to enroll in their ISD's welding program. He continued to live
in the Pine River district and he did not play sports at Reed
City. He then reenrolled at Pine River.
The Executive Committee denied
the request for waiver.
Macomb-Dakota
High School (Regulation I, Section 9 or 9[D]) - Request to waive the transfer
regulation was made on behalf of an 11th-grade student who enrolled
at Dakota Feb. 28, 2000, which is the Monday after the fourth
Friday of February, when Dakota High School was closed for winter
recess. If immediate eligibility was not granted, the request
was to waive the transfer regulation to permit eligibility after
90 school days of attendance at Dakota High School.
The Executive Committee granted
the request for waiver for immediate eligibility.
Marine City-Cardinal Mooney
Catholic High School (Regulation I, Section 9) - Request to waive the transfer
regulation was made on behalf of an 11th-grade student who relocated
from Virginia, where the student attended a Catholic high school,
to a home on Selfridge Air Base that is 18 miles from Harper Woods-Bishop
Gallagher and 21 miles from Cardinal Mooney Catholic High School,
from which the student's sister graduated in 1998. The student
had attended Cardinal Mooney's largest feeder school prior to
the move to Virginia.
The
Executive Committee granted the request for waiver.
Merrill High School (Regulation
I, Section 9) -
Request to waive the transfer regulation and specifically Interpretation
No. 71 was made on behalf of an 11th-grade student who was moving
to Belding with his family from Merrill. His father's employment
was transferred to Grand Rapids and his mother is employed in
Belding. They were renting an apartment in Belding while their
residence remained partially furnished and unsold in Merrill.
At its Aug. 16, 2000 meeting, the Executive Committee granted
the request for waiver when the school was satisfied that the
family had removed all personal belongings (not furniture) from
the Merrill residence and was not using that residence even intermittently
for residential purposes.
Because
the family could not satisfy all the conditions of the transfer
regulation for eligibility in Belding, on Aug. 23 this student,
who had been practicing with the golf team, and his 9th-grade
brother, who had been practicing with the football team and participated
in a scrimmage Aug. 15, reenrolled at Merrill High School. Request
was subsequently made to waive the transfer regulation and Interpretation
No. 69 on behalf of the 9th-grader.
The Executive Committee granted
the request for waiver.
Midland-Dow
High School (Regulation I, Section 9[B]) - Request
to waive the transfer regulation to permit eligibility only at
the subvarsity level during the first semester of the 2000-01
school year was made on behalf of a student who will be placed
as a second semester 9th-grader or first semester 10th-grader
after moving to the Midland High attendance area with his parents
from Brazil, where he did not participate in high school sports.
The
Executive Committee granted the request for waiver at the subvarsity
level only during the first semester of the 2000-01 school year.
Mt.
Morris-E. A. Johnson High School (Regulation I, Section 9) - Request to waive the transfer
regulation was made on behalf of an 11th-grade student who relocated
from the residence of his mother in the Burton-Bendle School District
to the residence of his father in Mt. Morris. The student's mother
and father were never married and the biological father is not
named on the student's birth certificate, although he has paid
child support. An otherwise completed Educational Transfer Form
was provided.
The
Executive Committee granted the request for waiver.
Novi High School (Regulation
I, Section 9) -
Request was made to waive the transfer regulation on behalf of
a 9th-grade student who practiced one day at Dearborn High School
while residing with her mother. She relocated to her father's
residence in Novi.
The
Executive Committee granted the request for waiver.
Pontiac-Northern High School
(Regulation I, Section 9) -
Request to waive the transfer regulation was made on behalf of
a 12th-grade student who attended Pontiac-Central High School
until October of 1999 when he was injured by another student.
He enrolled at Orchard Lake-St. Mary Preparatory School as a probationary
student. The student was unable to meet the conditions of his
probationary status and not allowed to return for 12th grade.
The Pontiac Board of Education placed him in Northern High School.
The
Executive Committee denied the request for waiver.
Pontiac-Northern High School
(Regulation I, Section 9) -
Request to waive the transfer regulation was made on behalf of
a 10th-grade student who attended Orchard Lake-St. Mary Preparatory
School in 1999-00 as a Spartan Foundation Scholar. He failed to
maintain the grade point average to continue on scholarship and
when the scholarship was revoked, the family could not afford
the tuition.
The
Executive Committee denied the request for waiver.
Pontiac-Northern High School
(Regulation I, Section 9) - Request
to waive the transfer regulation was made on behalf of an 11th-grade
student who moved from the residence of his mother in Auburn Hills
to the residence of his father in Pontiac. The parents were never
married. An Educational Transfer Form is in process. Birth records
identified these as the student's birth mother and father.
The
Executive Committee granted the request for waiver.
Portage Central High School
(Regulation I, Section 9[D]) -
Request was made to waive the transfer regulation on behalf of
an 11th-grade student who attended Schoolcraft High School for
two years before enrolling at Portage Central because of difficulty
with peers and depression.
The
Executive Committee granted the request for waiver.
Potterville High School (Regulation
I, Section 9[B]) -
Request to waive the transfer regulation to permit eligibility
only at the subvarsity level during the first semester of the
2000-01 school year was made on behalf of a 10th-grade student
who attended Charlotte schools from Kindergarten until winter
of 2000, her 9th grade, when she was withdrawn and schooled at
home through Faith Academy of Olivet. The student enrolled as
a tuition student at Potterville High School, which was not the
district in which her home is located, but the high school building
is closer to her home than Charlotte High School, where she did
play basketball as a 9th-grader.
Pursuant to the specific Representative
Council and school adopted prohibition of Section 9(B), which
would overreach the Executive Committee's authority to modify,
the request for waiver was denied.
Reading High School (Regulation
I, Section 9) -
Request to waive the transfer regulation was made on behalf of
a 10th-grade student who had been living with his father and was
returning to live with his mother and stepfather where he had
lived until his stepfather had a stroke. The mother and father
were never married. An otherwise completed Educational Transfer
Form was provided with birth and child support records identifying
these as the biological parents.
The Executive Committee granted
the request for waiver.
Redford-St.
Agatha High School (Regulation I, Section 9) - Request to waive the transfer
regulation was made on behalf of a 12th-grade student whose parents
divorced shortly after his birth. He lived with his mother in
California, attending Catholic grade school. In the 8th grade,
he moved to his grandfather's residence in Manistique where he
attended through grade 11. His grandfather passed away this summer
and the student moved to the residence of his father in Dearborn
Heights. Divine Child is the closest nonpublic school, but it
was not accepting new 12th-grade students.
The Executive Committee granted
the request for waiver.
Reese
High School (Regulation I, Section 9) - Request
to waive the transfer regulation was made on behalf of a 12th-grade
student who is the son of a pastor called to serve two United
Methodist Churches, one in Fairgrove and the other in Gilford,
and who moved with his family from Ohio to a church-provided parsonage
in Fairgrove because the parsonage in Gilford, which is within
the Reese School District, continued to be rented to another family.
The
Executive Committee granted the request for waiver.
Rock-Mid Peninsula High School
(Regulation I, Section 9) -
Request to waive the transfer regulation was made on behalf of
a 12th-grade student who attended Gladstone Public Schools since
age 5 but was the victim of harassment by other students during
the 1999-00 school year. She moved from her parents in Gladstone
to a residence in Rapid River, 1 Þ miles from Mid Peninsula
High School.
On
the basis of information from the offices of Delta County Sheriff
and Gladstone Public Safety, the Executive Committee granted the
request for waiver.
Saginaw-Nouvel
Catholic Central High School (Regulation I, Section 9) - Request was made to waive the
transfer regulation and Interpretation No. 69 to permit immediate
eligibility for a 9th-grade student who attended three days of
practice at Nouvel, then practiced two days at Saginaw-Heritage,
and now seeks to be eligible again in the sport of basketball
at Nouvel.
The
Executive Committee denied the request for waiver; the student
is ineligible only for basketball during the first semester of
the 2000-01 school year.
Sault
Ste. Marie-Sault Area High School (Regulation I, Section 9) - Request to waive the transfer
regulation was made on behalf of a 12th-grade student who attended
9th-grade at Sault Area High School before moving with her family
to Ontario. Her father recently took a job in Wisconsin and the
rest of the family moved back to Sault Ste. Marie.
The Executive Committee granted
the request for waiver.
Stockbridge
High School (Regulation I, Section 9) -
Request to waive the transfer regulation was made on behalf of
10th and 11th-grade brothers who relocated with their mother from
the residence of their mother and stepfather in Dansville to the
residence of her brother in Stockbridge. Both have played football
at Dansville.
The
Executive Committee denied the request for waiver and directed
that the Educational Transfer Form be utilized after the divorce
is final Sept. 15, 2000.
Suttons
Bay High School (Regulation I, Section 9[B]) - Request to waive the transfer
regulation to permit eligibility at the subvarsity level only
during the first semester of the 2000-01 school year was made
on behalf of a 10th-grade student who attended Granite Falls (Minnesota)
High School for 9th grade and did not participate in any MHSAA
sport.
The
Executive Committee granted the request for waiver at the subvarsity
level only during the first semester of the 2000-01 school year,
provided the student did not participate in any sport since first
entering high school.
Traverse
City Christian High School (Regulation I, Section 9) - A late request was made to
waive the transfer regulation, Interpretation No. 69, on behalf
of a 9th-grade student who was a student at Traverse City Christian
School in 7th and 8th grades. Her records were sent to Elk Rapids
and she practiced and played in one scrimmage with its girls basketball
team before enrolling at Traverse City Christian School on Aug.
31. The first day of classes for the school was Sept. 5.
The
Executive Committee denied the request for waiver; the student
is ineligible only for basketball during the first semester of
the 2000-01 school year.
Traverse
City West High School (Regulation I, Section 9) - A late request to waive the
transfer regulation was made on behalf of an 11th-grade student
who lives with his parents in Elk Rapids where he completed 10th
grade. He transferred to Traverse City West High School for its
block scheduling, ISD vocational program and dual programming
with Northwestern Michigan College. He will spend many weeknights
at the residence of a married couple who are both educators, one
of whom is this student's summer soccer coach.
The Executive Committee denied
the request for waiver, noting again that it must not base decisions
on comparisons of the curricula and scheduling of member schools.
Utica
High School (Regulation I, Section 9) -
Request was made to waive the transfer regulation on behalf of
an 11th-grade student who previously attended school in Abilene,
Texas, near where her father was stationed in the US Air Force.
He is scheduled to be transferred to Selfridge ANG Base in May
2001. In order to have her two final years at the same school,
her father gave custody to his sister, who lives in the Utica
High School attendance area.
Consistent with precedent for
flexibility in cases involving United States military assignments,
the Executive Committee granted this request for waiver; and it
also determined that this student will be ineligible for one semester
if she subsequently transfers to another MHSAA member school,
even if her circumstances would otherwise conform to one of the
stated exceptions to the transfer regulation.
Warren Woods Tower High School
(Regulation I, Section 9[B]) - Request
to waive the transfer regulation to permit eligibility at the
subvarsity level only during the first semester of the 2000-01
school year was made on behalf of a 10th-grade student who attended
Warren-De La Salle Collegiate High School for 9th grade and did
not participate in school sports.
The Executive Committee granted
the request for waiver at the subvarsity level only during the
first semester of the 2000-01 school year.
Hillsdale Academy (Regulation
III, Section 1[C]) -
Request was made to waive the enrollment regulation, Interpretation
No. 222, to permit 6th grade girls to participate with 7th and
8th-grade girls in basketball during 2000-01. The high school
enrollment is 43.
The
Executive Committee granted the request for waiver for girls basketball
only during the 2000-01 school year.
Hillsdale-Will Carleton Academy
(Regulation III, Section 1[C]) -
Request was made to waive the enrollment regulation, Interpretation
No. 222, to permit 6th grade girls to participate in the 7th and
8th-grade basketball program during 2000-01. This is a K-8 school
with 37 students (21 females) in grades 7 and 8.
The Executive Committee granted
the request for waiver for girls basketball only during the 2000-01
school year.
Holland-Calvary
Baptist School (Regulation III, Section 1[C]) - Request was made to waive the
enrollment regulation, Interpretation No. 222, to permit 6th grade
students to participate on 7th and 8th-grade girls and boys basketball
teams.
The
Executive Committee granted the request for waiver for girls and
boys basketball only during the 2000-01 school year.
Iron Mountain-North Dickinson
Junior High School (Regulation III, Section 1[C]) - Request was made to waive the
enrollment regulation, Interpretation No. 222, to permit 6th grade
girls to participate in 7th-grade basketball during 2000-01.
The Executive Committee granted
the request for waiver for girls basketball only during the 2000-01
school year.
Marcellus-Howardsville
Christian School (Regulation III, Section 1[C]) - Request was made to waive the
enrollment regulation, Interpretation No. 222, to permit 6th-graders
to participate on 7th and 8th-grade teams.
The Executive Committee granted
the request for waiver for the 2000-01 school year only.
Northern
Lakes Conference (Regulation III, Section 1[C]) - The league requested waiver
of the enrollment regulation and specifically Interpretation No.
222 to permit 6th grade students to participate with 7th and 8th-grade
students in boys and girls basketball, both of which are conducted
in the fall, under the condition that in each case, the high school
does not allow 8th or 7th and 8th-graders to participate on 9-12
grade teams under Regulation I, Section 1(D).
At its June 14, 2000 meeting,
the Executive Committee granted the request for Alba, Boyne Falls,
Ellsworth, Harbor Springs-Harbor Light Christian, Mackinaw City,
Vanderbilt and Wolverine High Schools for the 2000-01 school year
only.
The
conference resubmitted its request without the condition that
these school districts refrain from involving 7th and/or 8th-graders
in their 9-12 grade programs.
The Executive Committee granted
the request for the 2000-01 school year only in boys and girls
basketball.
Hillsdale
Academy and Hillsdale-Will Carleton Academy (Regulation III, Section
1[D]) - The
Executive Committee approved a cooperative program in boys soccer
at the junior high/middle school level. Hillsdale Academy will
be the primary school.
Leland
and Lake Leelanau-St. Mary Middle Schools (Regulation III, Section
1[D]) - The
Executive Committee approved a cooperative program in boys soccer.
Leland will be the primary school.
Royal Oak-Addams and Royal Oak-Keller
Middle Schools (Regulation III, Section 1[C]) - The Executive Committee approved
a cooperative program in wrestling. Keller will be the primary
school.
New
Schools - Pursuant
to the MHSAA Constitution adopted by member schools and according
to procedures for MHSAA membership as established by the Representative
Council March 21, 1997, the Executive Committee approved membership
for . . .
1.
Dearborn Heights-Academy for Business and Technology at
the high school level only, which has 235 students. It is anticipated
this public school academy will sponsor boys and girls cross country,
boys and girls basketball, golf, baseball, girls volleyball and
girls softball.
2.
Shepherd-The Morey Charter School at the junior high/middle
school and high school levels. The high school enrollment is 56
in grades 9 and 10 and competition exists in golf and girls basketball.
Enrollment will be closed at 160 students in grades 9-12 when
sponsorship of basketball, volleyball, wrestling, cross country
and golf is anticipated.
3.
Detroit-Weston Technical Academy at both the junior high/middle
school and high school levels. This public school academy has
160 students in grades 9 through 11 and intends to sponsor cross
country and basketball for both boys and girls.
Student Interest Survey Instrument
- Pursuant to
Representative Council action in May 2000, a tool has been developed
for schools' voluntary use to track student sports interests.
The Executive Committee suggested several changes and asked that
the instrument be reviewed by the MHSAA Athletic Equity Committee
before mailing to member schools.
Ramblewood Park Condominium
- An update
was provided regarding Unit 4 landscaping and Unit 5 building
delays and repair to Ramblewood Drive.
Statewide Sportsmanship Summit
- A status report
for the Sept. 27, 2000 event was provided.
Sponsorships - The support of United Dairy
Industries of Michigan for MHSAA student-athlete health and nutrition
initiatives has ended as a result of changing marketing approaches
by UDIM's national group. There was a report regarding new sponsorship
prospects for existing MHSAA initiatives.
Ruster Student Services - The Board of Directors of the
Ruster Foundation has determined to cease operations June 30,
2001, and has selected the MHSAA to receive the Foundation's remaining
funds. The Executive Committee approved acceptance of the grant
for a designated fund pursuant to the terms of the executive director's
Sept. 5, 2000 letter to the Foundation, reiterating that this
arrangement will be consistent with the existing framework, scope
and function of the MHSAA.
Personnel Matters - The Executive Committee reviewed
the executive director's evaluation and approved and signed the
executive director's 2000-01 Standards of Performance.
Next
Meetings - The
next meetings of the Executive Committee are Wednesday, Oct. 11,
at 9 a.m. in East Lansing; Wednesday, Nov. 8, at 9 a.m. in East
Lansing; and Wednesday, Nov. 29, at 8:30 a.m. in East Lansing.
n
EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE MEETING
East Lansing,
October 11, 2000
Executive
Committee Authority and Responsibility
- The Executive Committee was reminded of its authority under
Article VII of the MHSAA Constitution and specifically its responsibility
to consider each application for waiver of an eligibility requirement
on its individual merits, determining if the regulation serves
the purpose for which it was intended in each case or if the regulation
works an undue hardship on any student who is the subject of a
request for waiver. (These underlying criteria may not be restated
for every subject of these minutes.)
The Executive Committee was
reminded that it was the responsibility of each member school
involved to provide sufficient factual information about the specific
request for the Executive Committee to reach a decision without
further investiga-tion. If information is incomplete, contradictory
or otherwise unclear or has been received too late to be studied
completely, the Executive Committee may deny the request for waiver
or delay action. Such requests may be resubmitted to the Executive
Committee with additional information at a subsequent meeting
or appealed to the full Representative Council.
A determination of undue hardship
is a matter addressed to the discretion of the Executive Committee
within the educational philosophy and secondary role of voluntary
extracurricular competitive athletics in the academic environment.
The Executive Committee was cautioned to avoid making exceptions
that would create precedent that effectively changes a rule without
Representative Council action or local board of education adoption,
which would exceed Executive Committee authority.
Students for whom waiver of
a particular regulation is granted must be eligible in all respects
under all other sections and interpretations of the regulations
prior to their participation.
Consistent with rulings of the
Attorney General and Michigan Supreme Court, schools are not bound
by the decisions of the Executive Committee, but the association
may limit participation in the post-season tournaments it sponsors
to those schools which apply rules and penalties as promulgated
by the MHSAA and adopted by each member school's board of education.
The MHSAA exercises no independent authority over schools or students
during regular season.
Burton-Bentley,
Burton-Atherton and Genesee High Schools (Regulation I, Section
1[E]) - The
Executive Committee approved a cooperative program in wrestling.
Only Bentley High School has sponsored the sport previously and
it will be the primary school. The combined enrollment will be
902 for MHSAA tournament classification purposes (moving a Division
4 program to Division 2).
Negaunee High School (Regulation
I, Section 1[E]) -
Request was made to waive the Oct. 15 application deadline for
a cooperative program in girls softball between Negaunee and Ishpeming
High Schools.
The
Executive Committee granted the request for waiver until not later
than Nov. 1, 2000.
Traverse
City-St. Francis High School (Regulation I, Sections 4 & 5)
- A late request
to waive the semesters of enrollment sections of the eligibility
regulation was made on behalf of a student who completed 9th and
10th grades in Connecticut, repeated the 10th grade when he relocated
with his mother in the Virgin Islands, completed 11th grade in
Connecticut and is now enrolled for his 9th semester at St. Francis
High School in Traverse City where he lives with a family with
whom he has relocated from Connecticut.
The Executive Committee noted
that waiver has not been granted to students moving to or from
foreign countries and found that this student had been enrolled
in the maximum number of semesters permitted for eligibility.
Therefore, it denied the request for waiver.
Adrian-Lenawee Christian High
School (Regulation I, Section 9[B]) -
Request was made to waive the transfer regulation to permit participation
only at the subvarsity level for a 10th-grade student who attended
Lenawee Christian School through 8th grade. The father's vocation
relocated the family to Spring Lake and then to Morenci a few
months later. The student's application to attend Lenawee Christian
was denied because the school had reached capacity. The family
reapplied for the 2000-01 school year. The student played 9th-grade
basketball at Morenci.
Pursuant
to the specific Representative Council and school adopted prohibition
of Section 9(B), which would overreach the Executive Committee's
authority to modify, the request for waiver was denied.
Birmingham-Seaholm
High School (Regulation I, Section 9) -
Request to waive the transfer regulation was made on behalf of
an 11th-grade student who is relocating from the residence of
his birth mother to the residence of his birth father and transferring
from Redford-Detroit Catholic Central to Seaholm. Orders of Filiation
and Support dated 1985 identified paternity.
The Executive Committee granted
the request for waiver.
Bloomfield
Hills-Brother Rice High School (Regulation I, Section 9) - Request was made to waive the
transfer regulation on behalf of a 9th-grade student who is relocating
with his family because of his father's job transfer from Seattle
to the Troy area. Brother Rice may not be the closest nonpublic
school to his new residence but he has been attending one of Brother
Rice's associate schools in Seattle.
The Executive Committee granted
the request for waiver when the family completes its relocation
and has disposed of its previous residence pursuant to Interpretation
No. 71.
Burton-Valley
Christian Academy (Regulation I, Section 9[D]) - Request to waive the transfer
regulation to permit eligibility after 90 school days of enrollment
at Valley Christian Academy was made on behalf of a student who
previously attended Clio High School and will enroll at Valley
Christian on Oct. 11, 2000.
The
Executive Committee granted the request for waiver, effective
with the student's 91st school day of enrollment at Valley Christian
Academy.
Center
Line-St. Clement High School (Regulation I, Section 9[B]) - Requests to waive the transfer
regulation were made on behalf of two 10th-graders who attended
St. Clement grade schools and have returned to St. Clement High
School after attending other local Catholic high schools for 9th
grade where they did not participate in high school athletics.
The
Executive Committee granted the request for waiver at the subvarsity
level only during the first semester of the 2000-01 school year.
Chassell
High School (Regulation I, Section 9[C]) -
Request was made to waive the transfer regulation on behalf of
a 10th-grade student who resides in Chassell but attended Copper
Country Christian School for 6th through 9th grades. He played
in the basketball cooperative program of the schools during 1999-00.
The
Executive Committee granted the request for waiver in boys basketball
only during the first semester of the 2000-01 school year.
Dowagiac
Union High School (Regulation I, Sections 1[A], 9[B] and 9[D])
- A late request
was made to waive the enrollment and transfer sections of the
eligibility regulation to permit eligibility only at the subvarsity
level during the first semester and at the varsity level at the
start of the second semester of the 2000-01 school year on behalf
of a 10th-grade student who has relocated without his family from
Africa, enrolling Oct. 2, 2000. He has not previously played high
school sports.
Because
of the specific conditions of Sections 1(A), 9(B) and 9(D) and
the involvement in this and other proposed placements by the Mali
Director of National Sports Education and the basketball coaching
staff of a Midwest university, the Executive Committee denied
the request to waive the requirements for eligibility during either
the first or second semester of the 2000-01 school year.
Inkster
High School (Regulation I, Section 9 & Regulation V, Section
4) - The school
was requesting that the Executive Committee reinstate the eligibility
of a 12th-grade student who attended Inkster High School until
November of 1999 when he moved with his father to Southfield and
attended Southfield Lathrup High School. The student reenrolled
at Inkster High School March 4, 2000. Originally, MHSAA staff
was told by school administration and the father that the student
relocated to Inkster without his father and was advised by Inkster's
previous athletic director that if he enrolled by March 15, he
would be eligible at the start of the 2000-01 school year. More
recently, it was alleged but not established that the father relocated
with his son to an apartment within the Inkster School District.
On
Sept. 15, 2000, based on information available at that time, an
MHSAA assistant director advised the superintendent of schools
that the student was ineligible under the transfer regulation
and that Inkster High School must forfeit all contests in which
he had participated (the first three games).
On Sept. 25, 2000, based on
the fact that the school had provided no information that the
student had satisfied the transfer regulation before his participation,
and with a reliable report that the student had played in a football
contest (the fourth game) in spite of the assistant director's
earlier notification that the student was ineligible, the executive
director communicated to the superintendent that in view of these
violations, both inadvertent and intentional, and inasmuch as
the school was already on probation through the 2001-02 school
year for a long history of administrative violations, it was required
that the MHSAA now consider suspension of the school from participation
in MHSAA post-season tournaments through the probationary period.
The executive director asked for the school's written response
by Oct. 6, such response being received Oct. 6 and requesting
reinstatement of the student's eligibility.
Meanwhile, the MHSAA received
a member school's written allegation that this student played
in Inkster's sixth game on Sept. 30.
The Executive Committee noted
the long history of administrative violations by Inkster High
school and that neither meetings with Inkster School District
administration and board members nor imposition of penalties has
led to improved compliance. Also noted was the administration's
inability or unwillingness to withhold from competition a student
whose eligibility had not been established.
The Executive Committee found
there was insufficient evidence to determine the student is eligible
now, much less during the games in which he participated. It was
the Executive Committee's decision that the student remain ineligible
during the first semester of the 2000-01 school year, that all
games in which he participated be forfeited, that the school be
ineligible for MHSAA postseason tournaments in all sports during
the fall of the 2000-01 school year, and that the school's administration
appear before the Executive Committee in January to show cause
why the suspension from tournaments should not continue through
the 2001-02 school year.
Lansing
Christian High School (Regulation I, Section 9) - Request to waive the transfer
regulation was made on behalf of an 11th-grade student who attended
Lansing Christian for 9th grade. He transferred to New Covenant
Christian and then attended a military boarding school. He has
returned to his residence, which is closer to New Covenant Christian.
Citing
a lack of information that would demonstrate a compelling reason
for the student to attend New Covenant Christian, the request
for waiver was denied.
Leroy-Pine
River High School (Regulation I, Section 9) - For the Sept. 13, 2000 meeting,
a late request was made to waive the transfer regulation on behalf
of a 12th-grade student who attended Pine River Area Schools from
3rd through 10th grades. As an 11th-grader, he attended Reed City
Public Schools in order to be nearer the welding program of the
ISD of which Pine River is a member. He completed the welding
program. He continued to live in the Pine River district and he
did not play sports at Reed City. He then reenrolled at Pine River.
At its Sept. 13 meeting, the Executive Committee denied the request
for waiver. However, there was a misunderstanding of the facts
which justified reconsideration.
The Executive Committee denied
the request for waiver.
Pontiac-Northern
High School (Regulation I, Section 9) -
Request to waive the transfer regulation was made on behalf of
a 12th-grade student who attended Pontiac Central High School
until October of 1999 when he was injured by another student.
He enrolled at Orchard Lake-St. Mary Preparatory School as a probationary
student. The student was unable to meet the conditions of his
probationary status and not allowed to return for 12th grade.
The Pontiac Board of Education placed him in Northern High School.
At its Sept. 13, 2000 meeting, the Executive Committee denied
the request for waiver. The matter was resubmitted with additional
information linking the head trauma from the injury at Pontiac-Northern
with the inability to meet requirements for continued enrollment
at Orchard Lake-St. Mary.
The
Executive Committee granted the request for waiver.
Roseville High School (Regulation
I, Section 9) - Request
to waive the transfer regulation was made on behalf of a 10th-grade
student who attended 9th grade at Roseville Junior High but began
10th grade at Warren-Cousino High School. After eight school days
during which she did not participate in athletics, she enrolled
at Roseville High School. She participated in 9th-grade sports
during 1999-00.
The
Executive Committee granted the request for waiver, noting the
brevity of enrollment, lack of participation and return to original
school.
Saginaw-Nouvel
Catholic Central High School (Regulation I, Section 9) - Request to waive the transfer
regulation was made on behalf of a 9th-grade student who began
the current school year at Saginaw High School (where he played
football) before enrolling at Nouvel Sept. 20. There was concern
for the student's safety at the previous school.
The Executive Committee cited
the absence of independent verification of allegations and denied
the request for waiver.
Saginaw-Nouvel
Catholic Central High School (Regulation I, Section 9) - Request was made to waive the
transfer regulation and Interpretation No. 69 to permit immediate
eligibility for a 9th-grade student who attended three days of
practice at Nouvel, then practiced two days at Saginaw-Heritage,
and now seeks to be eligible again in the sport of basketball
at Nouvel. At its Sept. 13, 2000 meeting, the Executive Committee
denied the request for waiver, affirming that the student is ineligible
only for basketball during the first semester of the 2000-01 school
year. The school resubmitted the request Oct. 10.
Citing the short duration of
involvement at Heritage, conflicting accounts of what occurred
there and the fact that the student is enrolled where she first
practiced, the Executive Committee determined that Nouvel High
School could deem the student eligible only at the subvarsity
level after the 10th game of that subvarsity team schedule has
been played.
St.
Louis High School (Regulation I, Section 9) - Request to waive the transfer
regulation was made on behalf of an 11th-grade student who attended
St. Louis Schools from kindergarten until present except for Sept.
5-14, 2000, when he attended high school in Shepherd where his
sister is in middle school.
The
Executive Committee granted the request for waiver, noting the
brevity of enrollment, lack of participation and return to original
school.
Chassell
Junior High School and Calumet-Copper Country Christian School
(Regulation III, Section 1[D]) -
The Executive Committee approved a cooperative agreement in boys
and girls track and field and boys basketball between these junior
high schools.
Dryden
Middle School (Regulation III, Sections 1 & 8) - Request to waive the enrollment
and current semester record sections of the junior high/middle
school eligibility regulation was made on behalf of a 7th-grade
student who is enrolled for three courses at Dryden Middle School
and three courses at Dryden Country Day Academy, which sponsors
no interscholastic teams in any sport. The parents wish to withdraw
the student from all courses at Dryden Middle School but to keep
their son on the football team.
The Executive Committee noted
that the student's Individual Education Program Committee recommended
an academic program that would have had the effect of accessing
athletic eligibility opportunities for the student at either Almont
or Dryden Middle School, but the family rejected this plan. The
request for waiver was denied.
New Member Schools - Pursuant to the MHSAA Constitution
adopted by member schools and according to procedures for MHSAA
membership as established by the Representative Council March
21, 1997, applications for membership were approved for . . .
Battle
Creek-Family Altar Christian School
at the high school level only, enrollment 56, anticipating sponsorship
of boys and girls basketball, boys and girls soccer, baseball
and girls volleyball.
Charlevoix-Northwest
Academy, a public
school academy, at both the high school and junior high/middle
school levels. Grades 9-12 have 50 students and it is anticipated
that soccer, cross country, skiing and tennis will be sponsored
for boys and cross country, skiing and volleyball will be conducted
for girls.
Detroit-Michigan
Institute for Construction Trades and Technology at the high school level only.
The school operates under a charter from the Detroit Public Schools.
It has an enrollment of 250 students and will sponsor only boys
basketball.
Kalamazoo-Heritage
Christian Academy at
the high school level only, enrollment 100, anticipating sponsorship
of boys basketball and girls volleyball.
Upper Peninsula Swimming &
Diving Rules Meetings -
Because there have been no substantive changes in National Federation
swimming rules for two years and because Upper Peninsula schools
do not participate in a statewide meet but in a separate U.P.
Final Meet with qualification procedures and competition rules
(6 dives, rather than 11; no qualification standards; timed Finals,
not preliminary heats), it was proposed that the following occur
in lieu of requiring Upper Peninsula coaches and officials to
attend the rules meeting scheduled for Oct. 17, 2000:
1. Staff will send rules meeting
handouts and an exam to all 9 U.P. schools that sponsor swimming
and to all registered swimming officials in the U.P. (approximately
6).
2.
To receive credit, the exam must be signed by the official or
coach (coach's cosigned by principal or athletic director) and
be returned by Nov. 6, 2000, and receive a score of 70 percent
or better.
The
Executive Committee approved this plan for this sport and this
year only for schools and officials of the Upper Peninsula only.
Representative
Council - The
Executive Committee reviewed a draft agenda for the Nov. 29, 2000
Council Meeting. The committee also considered candidates for
appointed positions on the Council.
Additional Items - The executive director provided
brief updates regarding litigation, headquarters office lease
space, and construction issues involving Units 4 and 5 of Ramblewood
Park.
Proposal
1 - Some MHSAA
Representative Council members and staff are personally involved
and invested in efforts to defeat Proposal 1. The Executive Committee
reaffirmed that the MHSAA's role is to take the lead on sport-specific
issues that confront schools and to do so without financial support
from other organizations, while other groups assume leadership
on general issues without assistance from the MHSAA. The Executive
Committee observed that, through changes of leadership in the
organizations, this teamwork has proven effective for many years
on many issues, including at the present time when the MHSAA is
defending at great expense without outside assistance the sports
seasons decisions of school districts. The Executive Committee
expressed the hope that school district leaders would not allow
the tried and tested division of labor to create divisions between
the organizations, for nothing would better serve the purposes
of the opponents of education than to turn one organization against
another.
Next
Meetings - The
next meetings of the Executive Committee is Wednesday, Nov. 8,
at 9 a.m. in East Lansing; and Wednesday, Nov. 29, at 8:30 a.m.
in Traverse City. n
UPPER PENINSULA ATHLETIC COMMITTEE MEETING
Escanaba,
Sept. 15, 2000
Girls
Basketball Officials
The
committee selected officials for the 2000 Girls Basketball Tournament,
District, Regional and Final Round games. Jim St. Onge of Marquette
will work a Final game and Jerry Reddinger of Kingsford will officiate
at the Semifinals. St. Onge, Reddinger, Bob Lee of St. Ignace,
and Julie Hamar of Chassell will work games in the Quarterfinal
Round.
Boys
Basketball Sites
District Tournament as follows:
Class A: Marquette
at Escanaba
Class
B: Kingsford
Class
C: St. Ignace, Ishpeming, Hancock and Norway
Class D: Pickford, Big Bay de
Noc, North Dickinson, L'Anse, White Pine and Dollar Bay (hosting
at Michigan Tech University)
Regional
tournaments were assigned to Northern Michigan University for
Classes C and D. Regional 31 Class D games will be played at Pellston.
Quarterfinal Class D will be played at Escanaba
if the Regional 31 winner is from the UP. If Region 31 winner
is from the Lower Peninsula, the game will be played at Sault
Ste. Marie.
Golf Finals
June 1, 2001
Division 1: Marquette (boys
& girls)
Division
2: Munising (boys & girls)
Division
3: Bark River (boys)
Rock
Mid-Peninsula (girls)
Gymnastics Finals
The
Finals were assigned to Gladstone High School for March 3, 2001.
Hockey Regional Sites
Feb.
26 - March 3, 2001
Division
1: Marquette
Division
3: Houghton (hosting at MTU)
Ski Finals
Regional and Final sites will
be determined by the Ski Committee in October.
Swimming & Diving Finals
The
UP Swimming & Diving Finals will take place at Houghton High
School on Feb. 17, 2001.
Tennis Finals
June 1, 2001
Division 1: Marquette High School
Division 2:
Iron Mountain High School
(Only
Division 1 will incorporate a fourth doubles match for the 2001
tournament.)
Track & Field
Kingsford
High School will host the Finals for all three divisions on Saturday,
June 2, 2001. This is the second year of a two-year assignment.
The
committee determined that there would be two Regionals in both
Divisions 1 & 2, and four Regionals in Division 3.
In all three Divisions, schools
will be allowed four entries in each of the individual events.
Scoring will continue at 5, 3, 2, 1 (four places).
In Divisions 1 & 2, four
qualifiers from each individual event will advance to the Finals
and four relay teams will qualify in each of the relay events.
Single heats will be run in each of the track events with eight
entries.
In
Division 3, four qualifiers in each individual event will advance
to the Finals. This will provide 16 entries in each running event
necessitating two heats in those events. Two relay teams will
advance from each Regional.
Scoring
for all three divisions at the Finals will be 6, 4, 3, 2, 1 (5
places).
Regional
site assignments will be made at the January meeting in Escanaba.
Volleyball Sites
District
Tournaments
Class
A: Downstate
Class
B: Gladstone
Class
C: St. Ignace, Munising, Stephenson, and Ironwood
Class D: Cedarville, Engadine,
Crystal Falls and White Pine
Regional Tournaments
Classes
A & B: Downstate
Class
C: Newberry
Class
D: Bark River-Harris
Wrestling Finals
Individual
Finals will take place at Marquette High School on Feb. 16-17,
2001. This is the second year of a two-year agreement.
UP Final Trophy Policy
Because
of the new divisional setup for most UP Final Tournaments, the
following policy regarding runner-up trophies at Final tournaments
was adopted:
Only
championship trophies will be awarded in Gymnastics, Boys &
Girls Swimming and Boys & Girls Tennis.
Championship and runner-up trophies
will be awarded in Boys & Girls Cross Country, Boys &
Girls Golf and Boys & Girls Track & Field.
Next Meeting - Escanaba, Jan. 19, 2001. n
FROM THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR A LAKE LESSON
Among the very many very beautiful
drives in this state, one of my favorites is US Highway 2 between
St. Ignace and Engadine. Lake Michigan on one side, dense forests
on the other. When the sun is shining on the water, when the leaves
are turning, or when a new fallen snow is clinging, it's breathtaking.
During
a recent journey, I recalled a trip many years earlier when one
of my young sons found it difficult to comprehend that the water
we saw here was of the same body that washed up on the shores
of the Leelanau Peninsula, the Indiana Dunes, Lakeshore Drive
in Chicago and Door County in Wisconsin.
The same water touching shores
in many parts of Michigan, as well as Indiana, Illinois and Wisconsin.
As
the water of Lake Michigan connects many points of this state
and nearby states, so do certain principles connect the high school
athletic programs of different parts of this state and different
states. Separated by hundreds of miles and situated in different
time zones, schools and their communities approach the sponsorship
of interscholastic athletics with common themes: that these programs
are amateur, educational athletics - pure, wholesome, inexpensive,
local school sports.
The
waters of Lake Michigan are pretty clean now, purer than several
decades ago because people grew concerned for this fabulous natural
resource and became committed to its improvement and preservation.
So can it be with the unique American tradition of interscholastic
athletics: the programs are not perfect, they can be made better;
and with a commitment to amateur, educational athletics, this
great resource for our schools and society can be preserved and
even improved.
It
won't happen because a national organization says it should. It
won't come from state level rules and regulations. The improvement
will come only if, at the local level, those in charge of the
program and those working directly with young people want it to
happen and work for it, diligently and daily.
The effort is not life or death,
any more than purifying a lake or saving a national forest will
cure world hunger or cause world peace. But, just as with our
ecological efforts, improving educational athletics is worthwhile,
worth committing one's life to.
And those who commit their lives
to school sports, particularly at the local level, reap rewards
that people in few other professions will ever know. They witness
the return of boys and girls turned into men and women who will
say to you, "Thanks, you made a difference."
May
you find peace, satisfaction and happiness through your role in
school sports.

Any facet of interscholastic athletics that can unite more than
1,350 administrators, coaches, student-athletes and officials
under one roof for several hours has to be the paramount topic
in school sports today.
And thus, when such a crowd gathered at the Lansing Center on
Sept. 27 for the MHSAAs Sportsmanship Summit III, it served
as testimony that the issue of sportsmanship remains at the forefront
of athletic programs in schools throughout Michigan. Once again,
the Summit attracted the largest gathering ever to address sportsmanship
(1,353) , eclipsing the mark of 1,200 at the 1998 Summit.
The dynamic program began with a special presentation by the MHSAA
to long-time Michigan State University womens basketball
coach Karen Langeland, who recently retired after 24 years on
the sidelines where she exuded sportsmanship and character.
ESPN analyst Bill Curry delivered the keynote address, emphasizing
the important role that coaches play in molding student-athletes,
before the crowd was split into groups for various break-out sessions.
The event concluded with a luncheon as Grant Teaff, executive
director of the American Football Coaches Association, addressed
the audience while those in attendance signed a pledge agreeing
to adhere to the principles of sportsmanship as outlined in the
Arizona Sports Summit Accord.
THE SPORTS SUMMIT
ACCORD
At
the conclusion of the MHSAA Sportsmanship Summit III on Sept.
27, those in attendance were asked to read "Pursuing Victory
With Honor: The Arizona Sports Summit Accord," a document
outlining the principles of sportsmanship developed in 1999 at
a conference sponsored in part by the Josephson Institute of Ethics.
Michael
Josephson, president of that institute and CHARACTER COUNTS!,
spoke at the MHSAA Summit. During the luncheon, individuals were
asked to sign a pledge after reading the Accord, indicating their
willingness to adhere to the principles of sportsmanship.
Following
is the Accord, and a complete list of those who signed the pledge.
At its best, athletic competition
can hold intrinsic value for our society. It is a symbol of a
great ideal: pursuing victory with honor.
The love of sports is deeply
embedded in our national consciousness. The values of millions
of participants and spectators are directly and dramatically influenced
by the values conveyed by organized sports. Thus, sports are a
major social force that shapes the quality and character of the
American culture.
In
the belief that the impact of sports can and should enhance the
character and uplift the ethics of the nation, we seek to establish
a framework of principles and a common language of values that
can be adopted and practiced widely.
IT IS THEREFORE AGREED:
1.
The essential elements of character-building and ethics in sports
are embodied in the concept of sportsmanship and six core principles:
trustworthiness, respect, responsibility, fairness, caring, and
good citizenship. The highest potential of sports is achieved
when competition reflects these "six pillars of character."
2.
It is the duty of sports leadership - including coaches, athletic
administrators, program directors and game officials - to promote
sportsmanship and foster good character by teaching, enforcing,
advocating and modeling these ethical principles.
3. To promote sportsmanship
and foster the development of good character, sports programs
must be conducted in a manner that enhances the mental, social
and moral development of athletes and teaches them positive life
skills that will help them become personally successful and socially
responsible.
4.
Participation in athletic programs is a privilege, not a right.
To earn that privilege, athletes must conduct themselves, on and
off the field, as positive role models who exemplify good character.
5.
Sports programs should establish standards for participation by
adopting codes of conduct for coaches, athletes, parents, spectators
and other groups that impact the quality of athletic programs.
6.
All sports participants must consistently demonstrate and demand
scrupulous integrity and observe and enforce the spirit as well
as the letter of the rules.
7.
The importance of character, ethics and sportsmanship should be
emphasized in all communications relating to the recruitment of
athletes, including promotional and descriptive materials.
8.
In recruiting, educational institutions must specifically determine
that the athlete is seriously committed to getting an education
and has or will develop the academic skills and character to succeed.
9.
The highest administrative officer of organizations that offer
sports programs must maintain ultimate responsibility for the
quality and integrity of those programs. Such officers must assure
that education and character development responsibilities are
not compromised to achieve sports performance goals and that the
academic, emotional, physical and moral well-being of athletes
is always placed above desires and pressures to win.
10. The faculties of educational
institutions must be directly involved in and committed to the
academic success of student-athletes and the character-building
goals of the institution.
11.
Everyone involved in athletic competition has a duty to treat
the traditions of the sport and other participants with respect.
Coaches have a special responsibility to model respectful behavior
and the duty to demand that their athletes refrain from disrespectful
conduct including verbal abuse of opponents and officials, profane
or belligerent trash-talking, taunting and unseemly celebrations.
12.
The leadership of sports programs at all levels must ensure that
coaches, whether paid or voluntary, are competent to coach. Minimal
competence may be attained by training or experience. It includes
basic knowledge of: 1) the character-building aspects of sports,
including techniques and methods of teaching and reinforcing the
core values comprising sportsmanship and good character; 2) first-aid
principles and the physical capacities and limitations of the
age group coached; and 3) coaching principles and the rules and
strategies of the sport.
13.
Because of the powerful potential of sports as a vehicle for positive
personal growth, a broad spectrum of sports experiences should
be made available to all of our diverse communities.
14. To safeguard the health
of athletes and the integrity of the sport, athletic programs
must discourage the use of alcohol and tobacco and demand compliance
with all laws and regulations, including those relating to gambling
and the use of drugs.
15.
Though economic relationships between sports programs and corporate
entities are often mutually beneficial, institutions and organizations
that offer athletic programs must safeguard the integrity of their
programs. Commercial relationships should be continually monitored
to ensure against inappropriate exploitation of the organization's
name or reputation and undue interference or influence of commercial
interests. In addition, sports programs must be prudent, avoiding
undue financial dependency on particular companies or sponsors.
16.
The profession of coaching is a profession of teaching. In addition
to teaching the mental and physical dimensions of their sport,
coaches, through words and example, must also strive to build
the character of their athletes by teaching them to be trustworthy,
respectful, responsible, fair, caring and good citizens.
REVIEWING THE REGULATIONS HEALTHY PROGRESS
Recently we were asked to address
a national panel which was evaluating health concerns and services
within the state of Michigan. Our assignment was youth sports
issues; and of course, we could only address the interscholastic
level.
The
panel was not interested in hearing about the problems solved,
but the problems that remain; so we avoided most of the really
good news regarding the reduction of risk and the promotion of
health in school sports over the past 30 years, like how much
healthier wrestling is with the Michigan Weight Monitoring Program
and how much safer football is because of mouth guards, helmet
testing and certification, blocking and tackling rules. As requested,
we focussed on some of the current issues that concern us now
and will continue to do so in the near future.
I.
Use of anabolic steroids, androstenedione,
creatine, nutritional supplements, and over-the-counter and prescription
drugs for the enhancement of athletic performance and other purposes
was the first topic. It should continue to concern all of us responsible
for school sports.
We
have published statements from the National Federation of State
High School Associations warning against the promotion an