St Francis, Benzie Built to Contend Again

September 15, 2017

By Dennis Chase
Special for Second Half

TRAVERSE CITY – “Begin with the end in mind.”

Those words were at the heart of Julie Duffing’s preseason message to her Traverse City St. Francis cross country teams last month.

“It’s something we always talk about,” Duffing said. “We’re not really concerned about what’s going on right now. These meets give us an idea, but it’s the end of October and early November that we’re concerned about. We say, ‘Keep the end in mind. Where do we want to end November 4th?’”

The girls ended right where they wanted last November, successfully defending their MHSAA Lower Peninsula Division 3 title. They did it by turning a one-point loss to Lansing Catholic at the Portage Invitational into an 11-point win over the Cougars a month later at the Finals meet.

“They knew what had to be done,” Duffing said.

Well, the challenge might be even greater this fall, even though Lansing Catholic moved up to Division 2.

“They left, but now we have Hart,” Duffing said.

Hart, which finished seventh a year ago, stamped itself as the team to beat with a dominating performance at the season-opening Benzie Invitational. The Pirates won the large school division, topping Division 1 Traverse City Central by five points, 73-78. Benzie Central, which was third in Division 3 a year ago, was sixth with 165 and St. Francis seventh with 170.

To no surprise, Hart, led by individual Division 3 Final champion Adelyn Ackley, is ranked No. 1 in the first coaches poll. St. Francis and Benzie Central are tied at No. 2.

“They’re stacked,” Benzie Central coach Asa Kelly said of Hart. “As long as they stay healthy, they’ll be very tough to beat.

“But,“ he cautioned, “you can never tell. I think last year Hart was ranked fourth coming in (last year) and finished seventh.”

One month into the season, Hart has three runners with times among the top seven in Division 3. All are Ackleys (Adelyn at 16:54.5, Savannah at 18:43.6 and Alayna at 18:51.4). Benzie has two in the top 11 (Lucy Karpukhno at 18:51.1 and Sierra Pallin at 19:08.9). St. Francis has one in the top 10 (Joyana Tarsa at 19:08).

Kelly and Duffing, however, are of the same belief. They can’t worry about Hart. All they can control is how much their respective teams improve.

“We have a lot of work to do,” Duffing said. “We are coming along slowly, which is OK. We did last year, too. Our girls tend to come together for the bigger meets at the end of the season.”

The Gladiators, who run at Michigan State in the Spartan Invitational today, return five of their top six finishers from last year’s MHSAA Finals meet. Tarsa’s been the lead runner. She won the Buckley Invitational last Saturday with a time that was 42 seconds faster than a year ago on that course.

“Definitely a good thing,” said the 16-year-old senior, who finished eighth in LP Division 3 last year.

Katelyn Duffing gives the Gladiators a potent one-two punch when healthy. Her times have been slower than last year when she placed 11th at the Final. But the 16-year-old junior is also coming off mononucleosis.

“I feel 100 percent,” she said. “I feel a lot stronger. Maybe not quite (as strong) as in the past, but I’m working towards it. I still have time to improve.”

“If she comes back to form,” Kelly said, “they’re a whole different team.”

One runner who is making strides is junior Christine Scerbak, the No. 3 runner. She improved by 23 seconds at Benzie.

“She’s coming on,” Katelyn Duffing said. “She’s working hard and really pushing herself. She wants it. You can tell.”

“And that’s good because we need her up there,” Tarsa added.

Sophomore Libby Gorman, who was 35th at last year’s Finals meet, improved her times significantly at Benzie and Buckley, too.

Lauren Bramer, Nicole Polemitis, Madelyn Taylor, Abby Chittle, Athena Gillespie and Rori Richardson are battling for top seven positions.

After winning MHSAA titles the last two years, the Gladiators are not lowering their expectations.

Three-peating is their goal.

“We definitely have high goals,” Tarsa said. “We want to make it back and do really well. But we need to stay healthy. That’s one of my main worries.”

Julie Duffing is not thinking that far ahead yet.

“I go into every season hoping we do our best,” she said. “I’m not one to say we’re going to win it. That’s not how I coach. I go into it with the forethought that we have to work hard every day to get better.

“The girls set their goals at the beginning of the season and they said they would like to repeat. We (coaches) didn’t say anything about it. They know what they want to do, and we’re going to guide them.

“Hart is tough and you can’t count Benzie out. They’re tough, too. We’ll have to get tougher as the season goes on. But we’ll be ready.”

Kelly expects Benzie to be ready, too. The Huskies are led by two all-staters in Karpukhno and Pallin, who were 20th and 24th at last year’s Finals. Paige Johnston and Mary Claire Smeltzer are back and give Benzie a solid top four. Kelly’s mission was to find a No. 5.

And senior Hadley O’Connor, a first-year runner, is emerging as that candidate. She was fourth overall in the first Northwest Conference jamboree.

“She played volleyball three years and is a sprinter on the track team,” Kelly said. “She came to a summer running event, and four miles in she was still running with the top girls.

“I said, ‘Do you even know what you’re doing right now?’ She said, ‘I’m just running.’ I said, ‘You’re running with all-state girls, and you’re keeping up with them.’

“I thought she still was going to play volleyball, but the night before she called and said she was going to run cross. For her to show up was great news for us.”

Kelly, who coaches with his wife Tracie, said this could be one of Benzie’s best teams.

“Theoretically, it could be one of our top two or three fastest teams in school history, and we’ll probably be a longshot to win it,” he said. “Hart is that stacked.

“But we don’t talk about, ‘we’ve got to beat Hart, we’ve got to beat Hart.’ Right now we talk about how we can improve this team, how we can get our top five to where we want them and how we can get our 6-7-8-9-10 right on their heels. Those are the things we can control.”

Dennis Chase worked 32 years as a sportswriter at the Traverse City Record-Eagle, including as sports editor from 2000-14. He can be reached at [email protected] with story ideas for Manistee, Wexford, Missaukee, Roscommon, Ogemaw, Iosco, Alcona, Oscoda, Crawford, Kalkaska, Grand Traverse, Benzie, Leelanau, Antrim, Otsego, Montmorency, Alpena, Presque Isle, Cheboygan, Charlevoix and Emmet counties.

PHOTOS: (Top) Benzie Central’s Sierra Pallin (7) and Lucy Karpukhno, (6) and Traverse City St. Francis’ Katelyn Duffing (222) all are back pacing top-ranked teams this season after running against each other at last year’s Regional. (Middle) St. Francis’ Joyana Tarsa, left, has been the fastest on her team this fall. (Below) Karpukhno’s best time also ranks among the top 10 in LP Division 3 this season. (Photos courtesy of the Traverse City St. Francis and Benzie Central girls cross country programs.)

Grand Rapids Speedsters Dominate Division 2 Girls Cross Country Final

November 4, 2023

BROOKLYN — Emily Tomes of Grand Rapids Catholic Central might be the first MHSAA cross country champion to go all season without winning a meet until it mattered the most.

There are two good reasons for that.

First, she runs in the Grand Rapids area, which is a hotbed for high school cross country. Her biggest league rival, Selma Anderson of Grand Rapids Ottawa Hills, was the runner-up in the MHSAA Lower Peninsula Division 1 Final on Saturday.

Second, she was adjusting all season to a significant change in her training volume.

Natalie VanOtteren leads Grand Rapids Christian's team title run with a fifth-place finish.As a result, she had five second-place finishes in nine races and didn’t run faster than 18:25.5 until her conference and Regional meets.

“I ramped up my miles, so my legs felt tired for a lot of my races,” Tomes said. “So, that’s why I recently started running sub-18. My legs started to get used to the mileage. I was just trying to wait until this meet. This is when I was going to try to run my best.”

Tomes was the Division 2 champion, running a time of 17:31.4 on a Michigan International Speedway course that yielded fast times all day.

She won a kick down the stretch against St. Joseph senior Gail Vaikutis, who took second in 17:33.6.

“I feel like I do rely on my kick quite a bit, but I just knew it could help me pass those girls and it gives me a lot of confidence moving forward, ” Tomes said. “I have a couple postseason meets, so I’m really looking forward to those.”

It was anyone’s race when a pack of five runners reached the two-mile mark within one second of one another. It was a two-runner race coming down the straightaway, with Tomes passing Vaikutis in the final tenth of a mile.

“I don’t normally run in packs,” Tomes said. “This season kind of started off slower for me, so I wasn’t used to racing with these girls. I know they know how to run really fast. If I could just let them carry me along, it would help me out.”

Grand Rapids Christian won the team championship with a score of 112 points. Last season’s champion Otsego was second with 131.

The Eagles won their seventh MHSAA championship and first since 2014.

Senior Natalie VanOtteren, who defeated Tomes by 17 seconds at Regionals, led Grand Rapids Christian by placing fifth in 17:58.2. Sophomore Lilah Poel was 20th, sophomore Ellie Scholma 30th, senior Payton Holtz 31st and senior Naomi Nelson 65th for the Eagles.

Click for full results.

PHOTOS (Top) Grand Rapids Catholic Central's Emily Tomes, left, breaks away from St. Joseph's Gail Vaikutis during the closing stretch of the Division 2 Final. (Middle) Natalie VanOtteren leads Grand Rapids Christian's team title run with a fifth-place finish. (Photos by Dave McCauley/