Through the Years: Softball 1975-2015
June 28, 2016
By Geoff Kimmerly
Second Half editor
For more than three decades, the MHSAA Softball Finals have helped finish off another year of high school athletics in Michigan.
But as we begin this summer series of features on MHSAA tournaments from our spring issue of benchmarks, we'll kick off with softball and editor Rob Kaminski's look at the tournament's first 31 seasons.
We'll look at another MHSAA postseason event every Tuesday and Friday throughout this summer.
Mendon Ends USA's Title Streak, Starts Own with Commanding 1st Finals Triumph
By
Keith Dunlap
Special for MHSAA.com
June 14, 2025
EAST LANSING — Mendon wasn’t going to be denied this time – and in the process, the Hornets denied Michigan’s most record-setting softball program from adding another detail to its dominance over the last half-decade.
Seeking its record sixth-straight Finals championship, Unionville-Sebewaing was dethroned by a talented, motivated and determined Mendon team, which won its first championship with an 11-1 victory in the Division 4 Final at Secchia Stadium.
The game ended with two outs in the bottom of the sixth inning after Mendon’s 11th run scored on a throwing error by USA.
In short, Mendon (35-2) did to USA what USA (20-16) has been able to do so often during its stretch of dominance.
The Hornets also avenged one-run defeats to USA in the championship game (5-4) two years ago (5-4) and Semifinals (6-5) last year.
“You just keep working and keep working and you see the kids go through (the losses),” Mendon head coach Steve Butler said. “You come up short one year and then another year. We keep telling them, ‘You got this. You know you have it.’ To see them come through and pull it off and beat a team like that the way we did, it was awesome.”
Mendon started its onslaught by scoring four runs with two outs in the bottom of the first inning.
With the bases loaded, an infield popup by senior Ally Butler eluded two USA infielders and fell to the ground, allowing two runs to score.
Junior Cienna Nightingale then hit a 2-run double to give the Hornets a 4-0 lead.
Mendon got four more runs in the third, first when Nightengale hit another 2-run double just beyond the glove of the left fielder.
“All I was doing was swinging and swinging for my team,” Nightengale said. “I had girls in scoring position, and that’s what I did.”
Seniors Elise Allen and Abby Butler each followed with RBI doubles to put Mendon ahead 8-0.
USA scored its only run on an RBI single by junior Macy Prime in the fifth inning, but Mendon got that run back in the bottom of the inning on an error.
Mendon put runners on second and third base with one out in the sixth inning, finishing the game off on an RBI sacrifice fly by junior Taya Bingaman and throwing error by USA.
Steve Butler said it was a moment his team had counted down toward since leaving East Lansing last year.
“This group, they are motivated,” Butler said. “They know what they want. They’re goal-oriented, and they’ve had their eyes on this since we started.”
For USA, it will try and regroup and start another streak next year. Only four seniors will graduate.
“I think it’s possible the girls started to feel some pressure from the streak we had going,” USA head coach Marc Reinhardt said. “All good streaks, they have to end sometime. I thought Mendon played a heck of a game. We left a few plays out there that we didn’t make that cost us a few runs. We’ve been dealing with that on and off during the season.”
PHOTOS (Top) Mendon’s Ally Butler (27) high-fives her coach during Saturday’s Division 3 championship win over Unionville-Sebewaing. (Middle) The Hornets’ Gracie Schultz extends to snag a line drive in left field.