Elk Rapids' Smith Back on Course Just 2 Months After Severe Leg Injury
By
Tom Spencer
Special for MHSAA.com
August 30, 2024
Leighton Smith’s freshman year was nothing short of amazing as she competed for Elk Rapids High School’s first girls golf team in the fall and capped it off in the spring with a track school record and bragging rights as the fastest 400-meter runner in Northern Michigan.
But events this summer were even more astonishing.
A horse riding accident in June left the 15-year-old fighting for her life, experiencing multiple surgeries and then recovering through physical therapy.
To top it off, she returned to the links Thursday representing the Elks at the Petoskey Invitational played at the Bay View Country Club. Smith shot a 100 as the Elks placed seventh. Her score was tied for the team’s best and featured four pars.
It was an impressive next step, to say the least.
No one could have been prepared to endure what Smith experienced this summer. And no one could have been better prepared to do it than the Elks sophomore, according to doctors, her coaches and her parents.
She underwent five surgeries in six days. The first surgery was done by Dr. Justin Hollander and Munson Medical Center. Dr. Hollander placed a titanium rod in her right leg to stabilize a severe femur fracture.
Smith developed compartment syndrome, which is extremely painful and happens when there’s too much pressure around the muscles and that pressure restricts the flow of blood, fresh oxygen and nutrients to muscles and nerves. That pain and lying in a hospital bed began to impact her mental health but Smith and her parents, Melinda and Don Smith, knew she had the capacity to get through her complications.
Medical personnel, including Dr. Hollander, were extremely impressed with her determination, drive and attitude throughout.
“When you’re in a situation like this you have try your hardest to keep the most positive mindset and thoughts you can, because the mentality you have is what is really going to affect how you handle the whole situation,” Leighton Smith said.
Following that first surgery, she underwent multiple life and limb-saving surgical procedures called fasciotomies in both Traverse City and Grand Rapids. A fasciotomy involves cutting fascia to relieve tension or pressure in order to treat the resulting loss of circulation in acute situations.
“I am not used to being in a bed against my will,” Smith noted. “I was stuck there – you don’t realize the things you take for granted until you’re stuck there like that.”
Don Smith also serves as co-coach of the Elks girls golf team with Mike Newhouse. He witnessed his daughter’s horse riding accident and was there every step of recovery.
He couldn’t be more thrilled about what he witnessed in Petoskey as a father or coach.
“It is great to see her back and looking forward to the future,” Don Smith said. “We went from time in the hospital where you’re scared to even hear what the answer was going to be about sports and anything in life, and to be able to participate in golf here two to three weeks into the season.”
The sophomore has received MHSAA approval to use a cart during competition as a medical necessity, and she may be able golf in enough events this fall to participate in her team’s Regional in Tawas and possibly qualify for the Lower Peninsula Division 3 Final in Battle Creek.
“Leighton has greatly exceeded my expectations,” Newhouse said. “I initially thought she might lose the season, and if she could get back by midseason it would be a slow return. But her performance today far exceeded anything I expected.”
Golf really isn’t her favorite sport. Horse competition and track meets top that list. She is set to defend her 400-meter title next spring at the Traverse City Record-Eagle Honor Roll season-ending meet, and she is the only Elks student-athlete participating in rodeo, doing so through the Manton High School chapter of the Michigan High School Rodeo Association.
“I have a positive attitude and I don’t take it too seriously, but seriously enough that I can play the game,” she said of golf, while noting her primary motivation for being on the team is her father’s love of the game. “It is a good skill to have to be able to play golf, but it is definitely third on my list for sports.”
Third on the list is fine for her coaches.
“Dad will take it top three,” Don Smith noted while recalling moments after the final surgery at Helen DeVos Children’s Hospital. “The vascular surgeon talked with us for about 20 minutes and finally without us asking, he said she was going to be able to resume a normal life with sports and everything.”
And she has been back on a horse too.
“Now I am able to ride by myself pretty well, so I take him out every now and then and ride around the yard,” she said. “I think every time I get on, my Dad has a mini-heart attack – I think he’d prefer I never get on a horse again.”
Tom Spencer is a longtime MHSAA-registered basketball and soccer official, and former softball and baseball official, and he also has coached in the northern Lower Peninsula area. He previously has written for the Saginaw News, Bay County Sports Page and Midland Daily News. He can be reached at [email protected] with story ideas for Manistee, Wexford, Missaukee, Roscommon, Ogemaw, Iosco, Alcona, Oscoda, Crawford, Kalkaska, Grand Traverse, Benzie, Leelanau, Antrim, Otsego, Montmorency, Alpena, Presque Isle, Cheboygan, Charlevoix and Emmet counties.
PHOTOS (Top) Leighton Smith, left, consults with Dr. Justin Hollander during her recovery from horse riding injuries this summer. (Middle) Smith tees up a drive for Elk Rapids this season. (Below) Smith shares a moment with her horse. (Photos provided by the Smith family.)
Gladstone's Karl Siblings Talented In Taking to Air in High Jump, Pole Vault
By
John Vrancic
Special for MHSAA.com
May 30, 2025
ESCANABA — Three members of the Karl family have shown over the last few years a major interest in taking flight – at least from a track & field sense.
Gladstone sophomore Andrew Karl and his sister, freshman Maggie Karl, have found success in high jump, following older sister Kristy Karl – the girls school record holder in the event.
The younger two siblings also have shined in pole vault, Maggie tying the school record and Andrew just an inch away from doing the same on the boys side.
Kristy Karl, who has cleared 5 feet in high jump several times this season, owns the school record in that event at 5-foot-1 set a year ago. She will try to surpass that at Saturday’s Upper Peninsula Division 1 Finals at Kingsford.
“I need to put everything together,” she said. “Every time before I jump, I go over what I need to do. I started jumping in middle school. I figured out three-stepping this year and got the whole thing down.”
Kristy, who will attend classes at Bay College this fall, won high jump at 4-10 in the Regional on May 16 in Escanaba, and Maggie shared third place with Sault Ste. Marie freshman Isabelle McCord, both also at 4-10. Kristy also helped Gladstone win the 400-meter relay (52.56) and was runner-up in the 100 hurdles (16.97) on a lean by Escanaba junior Ava Stahlboerger.
Maggie Karl matched the school pole vault record with a winning leap of 9 feet as did senior teammate Chelsey Demeuse, who was edged on a tie-breaker as the Regional concluded Wednesday.
Boys’ pole vault started 12 days earlier, but was suspended after an Escanaba vaulter received injuries in a mishap during the Regional.
“It feels good to get this in,” Maggie said. “It’s so close to the Finals, although I think this is pretty helpful. I just wanted to qualify. How high you go depends on how you run (during the approach). I don’t remember exactly how I got started, but started jumping in seventh grade and I think it sparked an interest.”
Andrew Karl has soared as high as 14-3 in the pole vault this season, just an inch shy of the school record set by Josh Syverson in 2009.
He cleared 13 feet, good enough for third place as the Regional concluded.
“Changing the routine was the most challenging part,” he said. “You schedule your practices in advance. Consistency is key in any event. It’s a matter of deciding when to go hard and when to back off. I had plenty of height, but didn’t have the consistency with my pole.”
Maggie said she and Josh practice each Thursday during the summer at the Gladstone track.
“I think it helps,” she added. “Josh gives me pointers. Kristy doesn’t come down to the track quite as often, but she comes as much as she can and helps me with high jump.”
Josh, who started vaulting in middle school, is about to finish his third year of jumping.
“I like a good challenge, mentally and physically,” he said. “The biggest thing is to not think of it at all while you’re jumping because it becomes second nature. It’s a real balancing act. You’ve got to stick with it. It’s about consistency and never giving up. You just keep going.”
John Vrancic has covered high school sports in the Upper Peninsula since joining the Escanaba Daily Press staff in 1985. He is known most prominently across the peninsula for his extensive coverage of cross country and track & field that frequently appears in newspapers from the Wisconsin border to Lake Huron. He received the James Trethewey Award for Distinguished Service in 2015 from the Upper Peninsula Sportswriters and Sportscasters Association.
PHOTO Gladstone’s Andrew Karl clears the bar during the pole vault competition at this season’s Negaunee Lions Invitational. (Photo by Cara Kamps.)