Sturgis Girls Strong Again After 1st Finals Win, Surging in Repeat Pursuit
By
Scott Hassinger
Special for MHSAA.com
May 12, 2026
STURGIS – Sturgis girls track & field coach Lesley Starkey recalls working with a special group of young athletes a few years back in the Girls on the Run Program.
She is now reaping the rewards of that group's early introduction to running.
After winning the 2025 MHSAA Lower-Peninsula Division 2 Finals championship, Sturgis is off to another fabulous start this spring.
Led by seven returning runners who competed at the Finals a year ago, the Trojans haven't missed a beat despite losing some big-time contributors off that squad.
Sturgis has continued to thrive, completing the Wolverine Conference dual-meet season with a 7-0 mark and earning first in Friday's league meet in Vicksburg to capture a second-consecutive outright conference title.
Now the Trojans' attention shifts to repeating as Regional, St. Joseph County and Finals champions. The Trojans host their Regional on Friday.
Starkey, a native of Albion and a University of Michigan graduate, knew her team had the potential to do something out of the ordinary last season.
"We knew this group was special. I had watched these girls from the time they were in elementary school, junior high and they were very composed once they got to high school," said Starkey, a distance-running standout when she competed for the Wolverines.
The Trojans' coach used a situation at the 2025 Finals meet as an example when describing her athletes’ resolve.
"We were thrown a curveball last year at state with only one coach being allowed down on the infield during the meet. I decided that person should be Elton Raines, our sprint and relay coach,” Starkey said. “Our girls proved it wasn't necessary to have all us coaches there. They showed great maturity by doing it all on their own.”
J.B. Starkey, Lesley's husband, also grew up in Albion and then competed for Albion College in the steeplechase. Lesley teaches at Congress School in Sturgis, while J.B. is a physical education instructor at the high school and also the boys track & field coach. The couple have two children – 10-year old son Henry and daughter Alice, an eighth grader.
Sturgis' team was powered last season in the sprints and relays by now-Michigan freshman Keyanna O'Tey, who recently broke the Wolverines' record in the 200-meter dash at 23 seconds in the Duke Twilight Meet in Durham, N.C.
"Keyanna was home and came down and led our warmups at one of our practices. That shows that track & field is a path to something bigger in life than just sports," Lesley Starkey said.
Depth is once again a major strength at Sturgis with more than 50 athletes on the squad. The Trojans are especially strong in the relays and swept all four at the conference meet.
"Our relay teams have been huge for us this season. Our distance runners have also been a big focus, along with our hurdlers. Those kids have really stepped up and scored a lot of points in those areas," Starkey said.
Sturgis’ senior-dominated 3,200-meter relay of Sydney Bir, Tessa Hatt, Kinder Smith and Berkley Holtz has posted the second-fastest time in LP Division 2 this spring at 9:25.03 after earning third in the state as juniors.
"Winning state in the 3,200 relay has been in the back of our mind all year and we want to break our school record again. We have very good runners, and the coaching staff really pushes us. The girls before us set high standards and I believe we want to prove we can do that as well," said Bir, who will continue running at University of Wisconsin-Oshkosh and plans to study education with the intent of becoming a teacher and coach.
Among Bir's other goals before she's done with her prep career are to qualify for the Finals in the 400, in which she owns a personal-best time this year of 59.97.
Unlike most of her teammates, Smith concentrates solely on the four relay events.
"I really enjoy the relays because I'm so diverse in my running. I can go run a good 800 time in the longer relay and come back with a good 100-meter dash time in the 400 relay,” she said. “Everything can be individual in this sport, but we all know what we have to do to show up and get the job done for the team. No one complains, we just kind've lift one another up. It takes hard work and determination to get this done."
Smith will run for Spring Arbor University next and pursue a career as a nurse practitioner.
Sturgis' coach is excited about the Trojans' chances at the Finals in multiple events, especially the 3,200 relay.
"Sydney, Tessa, Kinder and Berkley are the most hungry event group of anyone on our team. They want to show what they can do. All four of them are college-bound runners. I've enjoyed working with them since they were really young, and its been so much fun," Starkey said.
Hatt signed recently to run cross country and track at North Central College, where she will study psychology with plans to obtain a degree in pediatric pre-occupational therapy.
"I used to want to be a teacher, but I became interested in helping kids in a different way," Hatt said.
In addition to the 3,200 relay, Hatt concentrates on the open 1,600 and 800 as well. She qualified for the Finals her junior year in the 800.
"We added Kinder to the 3,200 relay last year, and we all just really clicked. Since then we have all just done our part, and everything we do is to obtain the goal of winning state,” Hatt said. “Sydney gets out to such a strong start for us before she gives the baton to me. I try to maintain that. Kinder is faster than most teams’ third-leg runners, and Berkley does such a great job of chasing.”
Smith, Holtz and Bir team up with sophomore Olivia Green in the 1,600 relay, where the Trojans rank fourth in 4:10.01. Sophomore Addison Eicher, Smith, freshman Madelyn Oswald and senior Angela Cary are rated fifth in the 400-meter relay (50.87). Eicher, Cary, Bir and Smith comprise the team’s fourth-ranked 800-meter relay (1:47.21). The quartet already have met the Finals-qualifying time.
Cary has shined brightly in the high jump, where she is tied for third-best at 5-foot-5. She also long jumps (16-1) and competes in the two relays.
"As a junior I was only about a quarter inch off the school record in the long jump. I've been working on my landing, and that's a big key to reaching my goals there," she said.
"As a group we all enjoy spending time together. Our close connection is a big thing with this team. It helps to avoid any drama. We definitely are looking forward to Regionals and winning state again."
Holtz recently broke Ann Marie Arseneau's 10-year school record in the 3,200-meter run with a time of 11:09.63.
"I was feeling really good that day and just went for it. They had combined the boys and girls races and I ran with one of my friends from the guys team. It was a little unexpected considering I hadn't ran the 3,200 since I was a freshman. The meet was against Otsego, so we were just trying to score as many points as possible to win," said Holtz, who has prospered following a late-season ankle injury as a junior that required offseason surgery.
Holtz credits Sturgis' success on the track to her team's strong work ethic and a solid coaching staff.
"Our success is built on great teamwork. We all work well together and lift each other up. Our coaches put in a great deal of effort and that encourages us to give 100-percent effort during practice and running faster times," said Holtz, who plans to study nursing at U-M.
Holtz also owns Sturgis' school record in the open 800 (2:16).
Oswald is also a rising star in the pole vault with a personal-best effort of 9-9.
"Madelyn is a very versatile kid who has made a very big impact so far," Starkey said.
While Sturgis is relatively young in the throws, junior Vivian Massey – last year's Division 2 adaptive shot put champion, returns for her third season and is primed to repeat. She is a two-time Finals qualifier and placer.
"We graduated some good kids last season, but the leadership our current seniors bring to practice every day has helped shape our younger kids. It shows that they can be just as successful if they are willing to put in the work as well,” Starkey said. “This is a real driven group who are super positive, and they celebrate each other's success. Their main goal is to build on the program's success. We have great team chemistry and a lot of these girls run cross country, play basketball and the opportunity to spend time so much time together has created a tight bond.”
Scott Hassinger is a contributing sportswriter for Leader Publications and previously served as the sports editor for the Three Rivers Commercial-News from 1994-2022. He can be reached at [email protected] with story ideas for Berrien, Cass, St. Joseph and Branch counties.
PHOTOS (Top) Sydney Bir, right, hands off the baton in the 800-meter relay to senior teammate Kinder Smith during a meet. (Middle) Berkley Holtz carries the baton during her leg in the 3,200-meter relay. (Below) Senior Tessa Hatt prepares to take the baton from a teammate during the 3,200-meter relay this season against Otsego. (Photos provided by Sturgis Public Schools.)
Time at Track is Nesbitt Family Time Too
By
Paul Costanzo
Special for MHSAA.com
April 19, 2017
Conversations in the Nesbitt house always seem to come back to track and field.
The fact that the father, Michael, is the cross country and boys track coach at Bay City Western, and his two children, Brendan and Sydney, are MHSAA Finals qualifiers in both sports is only part of the reason.
“Having my dad as a coach is different because he’s with you like every second of basically every day,” Brendan Nesbitt said. “When you’re at practice when he tells you something, he’s not telling you as your dad, he’s telling you as your coach. Then at home, he’ll switch gears. Even when we come home, we talk a lot about track or cross country, but that’s just because we’re really big track nerds.”
Time at the track is time with family for the Nesbitts.
Brendan is a senior at Western who finished seventh in the Lower Peninsula Division 1 meet a year ago in the 800 meters. Sydney is a sophomore who qualified in the same event her freshman year.
Michael has been coaching at Western for 19 years, and while recently his children have been a big part of that, they’ve never really been that far away.
“It wasn’t just my wife and myself raising the kids,” Michael said. “The athletes would babysit them on some nights, and they were teaching them to run hurdles and things like that.”
Running runs in the family, as both Michael and his wife, Deanna, were collegiate runners. Michael’s father, Jim, was his coach at Saginaw Valley State University.
During Michael’s childhood, while his dad was a high school coach, he spent time carrying athletes’ sweats, or anything else that would put him near the team and his dad.
Two decades later, Brendan – who also will run at Saginaw Valley – was doing the same thing.
“I’m the oldest sibling, so I didn’t have other siblings to look up to, I guess,” Brendan said. “I was always at the team dinners the day before the meets, and I had fun and looked up to them. They treated me like a little brother.”
Sydney, meanwhile, has had a unique experience. Not only did she grow up around the track and cross country teams, she also has had a brother on those teams – and at home – that she has admired and followed.
“During the summers I’ve been training with my dad and the high school team since like sixth grade,” she said. “I knew what Brendan was like, and how hard he trained, and I wanted to be like him.”
Brendan said he’s passed some knowledge onto his sister, for instance, like the importance of getting up each weekend and going for a run even when she’d rather not. But he said her teammates and her talent are doing the bulk of the work.
“Coming out of middle school, we knew she was going to be pretty good. We just didn’t know how good,” he said. “Since I’ve been on the team, she’s been around the high school team more, and she saw me and how I adjusted to high school races. When she came in, our girls team had a bunch of good older girls. My class is big on the girls side, and she knew a lot of them, so they taught her most of the stuff.”
They couldn’t give her what Michael did on the day of the 2016 MHSAA Finals, however. In her first time running at the meet – she had been there several times as a spectator – Sydney was too excited to be overwhelmed after watching her brother come from the middle of the pack in the boys 800 to run a personal best time of 1 minute, 54.85 seconds and earn an all-state medal.
While Sydney didn’t place among the top eight, she ran her own personal best of 2:18.14 to finish 17th in Division 1.
“It was always amazing to be at the state meet – the atmosphere was so cool – and I always wanted to be part of that,” Sydney said. “My brother ran before me and he got seventh in the state, so that was a huge motivating factor.”
It was, of course, a big moment for Brendan, too. He remembers making his final kick after hearing his dad and grandfather giving encouragement and guidance with about 250 meters to go. After he crossed the finish line, he looked back and the first face he saw was his father’s.
“I turned and looked at my dad right away,” Brendan said. “He’s standing at the 50-yard line and he’s holding up the numbers on his hand that he had on the hand timer. Basically, I walked over to him and gave him a hug, then gave my teammates a hug.”
Being the first person to greet a runner at the finish line is both a duty and a perk of being a coach. Being the first to greet your son after an all-state performance? That’s something else altogether.
“I try to internalize most of the dad part when I’m coaching,” Michael said. “I know it’s my son out there, but he’s also a runner for Western high school. He’s a runner for me on the track. But it was a pretty emotional moment when he earned his medal at the state meet. That’s a proud dad moment. That’s when it comes to reality – after the race.”
While he gets them in the fall and spring, Michael isn’t always coaching his children. Technically, he’s not the girls track coach, either. That job belongs to Rich Syring, although Michael is the distance coach, so he does oversee most of Sydney’s workouts.
During basketball season, however, he’s just dad.
“It was nice when they got into middle school and high school, I got to take the dad seat in the stands,” Michael said. “To be coached by someone else, that’s a good experience. You have to know it’s not dad out there, and that somebody else is going to yell at them. I like the basketball, just the idea of them getting exposure in a different sport. I think it helps them become not just a better runner, but a better athlete.”
Just because he’s not the coach, however, doesn’t mean his presence isn’t felt.
“For basketball, he doesn’t coach, but he’s definitely the loudest in the stands,” Sydney said with a laugh. “If something goes wrong, he’ll give me a look. I know what he’s saying just with that look.”
Paul Costanzo served as a sportswriter at The Port Huron Times Herald from 2006-15, including three years as lead sportswriter, and prior to that as sports editor at the Hillsdale Daily News from 2005-06. He can be reached at [email protected] with story ideas for Genesee, Lapeer, St. Clair, Sanilac, Huron, Tuscola, Saginaw, Bay, Arenac, Midland and Gladwin counties.
PHOTOS: (Top) From left, Brendan, Michael, Sydney and Deanna Nesbitt at the 2016 Division 1 Finals. (Middle) Brendan Nesbitt, in yellow, works to move up from the middle of the pack during the 800. (Top photo courtesy of the Nesbitt family, middle by Carter Sherline/RunMichigan.com.)