St. Mary Erases Doubts, Ends Ithaca Run

November 28, 2014

By Bill Khan
Special for Second Half


DETROIT — The players and their coach insisted they were playing for their own glory, not to deprive Ithaca of further greatness.

Monroe St. Mary would've savored an MHSAA Division 6 football championship regardless of the opponent, regardless of the historical backdrop.

But when the clock expired on the Falcons' 22-12 victory over Ithaca on Friday at Ford Field, once they'd secured their first title since 1991, there was a little extra pride among the St. Mary players.

Yeah, it was pretty special to beat a team with a nation-leading 69-game winning streak and four consecutive Division 6 championships.

"At the beginning of the week, we didn't really think about that," St. Mary senior linebacker David Howey said. "The coach just kept preaching there's 48 minutes left in high school football. That's a pretty cool win, though, beating the nation's longest winning streak in high school football. It's pretty cool. When we told people that's who we were going to play, they'd doubt us, and that just fueled me even more."

There was also a bit of a revenge motive for St. Mary (13-1), which lost 45-35 in the Division 6 final when the Yellowjackets' string of MHSAA titles began in 2010.

"It makes it a little more sweet, but it's just awesome," said senior John Lako, who ran for two touchdowns and made seven tackles with a sack at linebacker. "I was actually at the game when we lost to them in 2010. Just to see they were that close, it feels like we finally wrote the end of the book."

Ithaca coach Terry Hessbrook hasn't had to deliver a postgame speech to his players following a loss since a 47-16 setback to Montague in a 2009 Division 6 Semifinal. From the start of 2010, the Yellowjackets assembled a winning streak that ranks 13th all-time in national high school football history. The streak included 24 consecutive playoff victories. Ithaca was trying to tie the record of five straight MHSAA titles shared by Farmington Hills Harrison (1997-2001) and East Grand Rapids (2006-10).

Ithaca had to come from behind in its previous two games just to keep the streak alive and return to Ford Field. The Yellowjackets trailed Madison Heights Madison 27-19 heading into the fourth quarter of the Regional Final before winning 41-27.

They made a stop on fourth down from the 4-yard line with 13 seconds left to preserve a 20-16 Semifinal victory over Boyne City, which took an early 14-0 lead.

"We've had maybe more talented teams, I'm going to be honest, and that's no knock on this football team," Hessbrook said. "But I've never coached a football team that has more heart and more resiliency, and that's going back to the teams we've had in the last four or five years. I don't care what team you put out there, this team will fight you every step of the way. I couldn't be more proud. We came up short. We missed a few opportunities. We came up a few plays short. One play in the kicking game, one play here or there on offense, we win that game, and we win it going away."

Ithaca (13-1) had only three victories with a margin of fewer than 10 points during the winning streak. Missed extra points by opponents played a major role in two of those games, a 22-19 overtime victory over Montague in the 2011 Regional Final and a 21-20 victory over Montrose in a 2013 Semifinal.

Ironically, points after touchdown were critical in the outcome of Friday's championship game.

Monroe St. Mary's edge in conversions began following the first touchdown of the game, a 2-yard run by Lako that capped an opening drive that milked the first 8:15 off the clock. An off-sides penalty by Ithaca on the extra point attempt moved the ball close enough to the goal line to make a two-point attempt more feasible. Justin Carrabino ran untouched around the right side to give St. Mary's an 8-0 lead.

Ithaca tried to make up the difference following its first touchdown, an 11-yard pass from Jake Smith to Spence DeMull with 9:20 left in the second quarter, but the two-point pass fell incomplete to leave St. Mary's up 8-6.

Special teams loomed even larger with 7:11 left in the second quarter when Troy Hilkens forced a fumbled punt return. The ball popped up to Travis Vuich, who returned it 19 yards for a touchdown. Phillip Lehmann's extra point made it 15-6.

"It was a great feeling," Vuich said. "The guys did their job on the punt filling the lanes. The ball just popped right up."

Ithaca found the end zone for a second time on a 2-yard run by Smith with 33 seconds left in the first half. The extra-point attempt hit the upright, leaving the Yellowjackets down by a 15-12 margin despite matching St. Mary's two touchdowns.

"I hope that all those young people who were standing on our sideline understand what a small margin for error there is when you play for a state championship and understand how much work goes into it," Hessbrook said.

An Ithaca offense that averaged 43 points a game wouldn't score again, as St. Mary came up with huge defensive stops in the second half.

On fourth-and-one from the St. Mary 21, Ithaca was stopped in the backfield by Justin LaPlante and finished off by Darius Marks for a 1-yard loss with 2:29 left in the third quarter.

Ithaca marched to St. Mary's 19 on its next possession, but Bryce Windham (also the Falcons' quarterback) intercepted a pass after a reverse.

St. Mary's took over at its own 2-yard line with 10:19 remaining and was able to milk the clock down to 2:46 before punting. Ithaca got the ball at its own 20 for one final attempt to keep its winning and championship streaks alive. On second and 10, Lako sacked Smith for a 12-yard loss with 2:19 to go. On fourth-and-22, Marks intercepted a pass with 1:51 remaining and returned it to the 5.

Two plays later, Lako wrapped up the victory with a 3-yard touchdown run with 1:41 left.

Ithaca threw four incompletions on its final possession, and St. Mary kneeled out the clock.

"We won today because of our defense," St. Mary coach Jack Giarmo said. "Offensively, we struggled a little bit, but defensively the kids just did a fantastic job battling."

Ithaca outgained St. Mary, 262-182, but had three costly turnovers. Smith ran 18 times for 90 yards and a touchdown while completing 14 of 29 passes for 147 yards, one touchdown and one interception. DeMull caught nine passes for 108 yards and a touchdown.

Vuich made two clutch catches for first downs when St. Mary took 7:33 off the clock following Windham's interception. Vuich caught three passes for 38 yards, accounting for more than half of Windham's 71 yards on 7 for 12 passing.

LaPlante had nine tackles, including two for losses, to lead St. Mary's defense. Reeser had a game-high 12 tackles for Ithaca.

Click for full statistics.

PHOTOS: (Top) Monroe St. Mary Catholic Central players raise their first MHSAA football championship trophy since 1991 on Friday. (Middle) St. Mary defensive back Darius Marks (2) snags an interception in front of an Ithaca receiver. (Click for action photos and team photos from Hockey Weekly Action Photos.)

VIDEO HIGHLIGHTS:

SMITH TO DEMULL FOR THE SCORE - Ithaca scores its first touchdown in the second quarter, with Jake Smith finding Spence DeMull in the end zone for the score.
 
FALCON FINDS GOOD FORTUNE - On its drive following the first Ithaca TD, Monroe St. Mary Catholic Central punts and a loose ball on the return finds its way into the hands of Travis Vuich, who took it 19 yards for what proved to be the winning points.

Watch the entire game and order DVDs by Clicking Here. 

1st & Goal: 2026 Playoffs Week 3 Review

By Geoff Kimmerly
MHSAA.com senior editor

November 16, 2026

Four teams are set to play for MHSAA Football Finals championships. Another 32 are one more win from doing the same. 

MI Student AidWe’re down the final two weeks – and 36 contenders – with several familiar faces still in the mix for this season’s titles and a handful more we haven’t seen before or at least in a while. Here are quick looks at how all 36 took the next steps over the weekend.  

8-Player Division 1

HEADLINER Deckerville 42, Pickford 28 The Eagles (11-1) are headed back to Superior Dome for the second time in three seasons after winning this repeat matchup of the 2024 Division 1 Final in Marquette – also won by Deckerville. The Panthers finished 9-3, all of their losses to teams that advanced to the Semifinals. Click for more from the Huron Daily Tribune.

HEADLINER Blanchard Montabella 56, Colon 21 The Mustangs (11-1) will return to the Superior Dome for the second-straight season after finishing Division 1 runner-up a year ago, and their margin of victory continues to be stunning as this was their ninth win by at least 35 points. Colon finished 10-2, its only other loss to Mendon – which will also play for a title. Click for more from the Mount Pleasant Morning Sun. 

8-Player Division 2

HEADLINER Gaylord St. Mary 39, Portland St. Patrick 36 There’s no arguing with St. Mary’s path to the Finals as the Snowbirds (12-0) defeated an unbeaten opponent for the second-straight week, this time ending the reigning Division 2 champion Shamrocks’ 24-game winning streak. St. Mary will be playing in its first Final since 2002. Click for more from the Petoskey News-Review.

HEADLINER Mendon 58, Britton Deerfield 34 Once again, the Mendon ground attack was simply too much to stop. Xavior Zinsmaster ran 40 times for 312 yards and five touchdowns as the Hornets (12-0) rushed for 526 yards total. Chase Stetler did throw for 321 yards and five touchdowns for the Patriots, who finished 9-3 in making the Semifinals for the second time in three seasons. Click for more from the Sturgis Journal.

11-Player Division 1

HEADLINER East Kentwood 23, Portage Central 20 A tipped fourth-down pass with less than a minute to play landed in Zeke Ferrell’s hands and put East Kentwood (12-0) ahead to stay. The Regional title was the Falcons’ second straight and prevented Portage Central (10-2) from accomplishing the same. Click for more from WOOD TV.

Regional Roundup Detroit Catholic Central 21, Clarkston 7 In a repeat result of this matchup from a year ago – although by a 50-percent smaller margin – DCC (11-1) claimed a third-straight Regional title and again ended Clarkston’s season at 10-2. Detroit Cass Tech 40, Northville 30 The Technicians (12-0) also won a playoff rematch from last season, claiming their third-straight Regional title and fourth over the last five seasons and ending Northville’s second Regional run over the last four years at 9-3. Romeo 16, Rochester Hills Stoney Creek 9 Romeo (12-0) claimed its first Regional title since 2016 with two touchdowns by Landen Fetty including one on a hook-and-ladder. Stoney Creek ended its longest playoff run and winningest season at 9-3. 

11-Player Division 2

HEADLINER Orchard Lake St. Mary’s 48, Bloomfield Hills Brother Rice 14. St. Mary’s (9-3) won this rematch by nearly the same score as when these Catholic High School League rivals met in Week 5, taking it up a notch defensively after prevailing the first time around 48-20. Rice finished 9-3, its only other loss this season to Toledo Central Catholic, which remains alive in the Ohio playoffs. Click for more from the Oakland Press. 

Regional Roundup Milford 26, South Lyon 20 Milford (11-1) avenged a 49-18 Week 4 loss to South Lyon (9-3) to claim its first Regional championship in this sport. Muskegon Mona Shores 45, Byron Center 28 After winning their first meeting this season by just a point in Week 6, Mona Shores (11-1) pulled away from the Bulldogs (9-3) to claim a first Regional title since 2020. Grosse Pointe South 50, Livonia Franklin 13 The Blue Devils (11-1) locked up their first Regional title since 2010 with one of their strongest performances yet on both sides of the ball. Franklin (9-3) was playing in its first Regional Final since 2022.

11-Player Division 3

HEADLINER DeWitt 41, Mount Pleasant 24 The rematch of last season’s Division 3 Final went the reigning champ Panthers’ way again. After leading by six at halftime, DeWitt (10-2) pulled away to claim its eighth Regional title over the last nine seasons and end Mount Pleasant’s run this fall at 10-2. Click for more from the Lansing State Journal.

Regional Roundup Chelsea 42, Mason 24 Chelsea (12-0) is headed to the Semifinals for the first time since 2021 after handing Mason (10-2) its second defeat with Gibby Ichesco running for three scores and Jax Ichesco for two. Harper Woods 38, Warren De La Salle Collegiate 13 Harper Woods clinched its third Regional title over the last four seasons, and first in Division 3. De La Salle ended its Regional title repeat pursuit at 7-5. Zeeland West 30, Middleville Thornapple Kellogg 24 The Dux (10-2) also are in a familiar spot with their third Regional title over the last four seasons. MTK finished its longest tournament run since 2001 at 9-3.

11-Player Division 4

HEADLINER Dearborn Divine Child 21, Goodrich 14 Just like a year ago, these two played a defense-dominated nail-biter as the reigning champion Falcons (11-1) made several big plays this time to hold off the Martians (11-1). Divine Child had defeated Goodrich 10-7 in a Semifinal last fall, and the Martians’ only losses over the last two seasons came against the Falcons. Click for more from the Detroit Free Press.

Regional Roundup Grand Rapids Kenowa Hills 42, Hudsonville Unity Christian 21 Kenowa Hills (11-1) secured its first Regional championship since 1992 by scoring the most points Unity (7-5) had given up since Week 1 against Divine Child. Grand Rapids South Christian 35, Portland 20 The Sailors (11-1) avenged a one-point District-opening loss to Portland (11-1) from a year ago to win their fourth Regional title over the last five seasons. Detroit Country Day 21, Macomb Lutheran North 13 The Yellowjackets (9-3) claimed their first Regional championship since 2022 with another fantastic defensive performance, as Lutheran North (10-2) entered the game scoring an average of 35 points per contest.

11-Player Division 5

HEADLINER Frankenmuth 27, Saginaw Swan Valley 21 The Eagles  (11-1) held on against the rival Vikings in a rematch highlighted by their four-down goal-line stand followed by a safety and another Swan Valley score with less than a minute to play to pull the Vikings (10-2) back within striking distance. Both of Swan Valley’s losses this season came to Frankenmuth over the last five weeks. Click for more from the Saginaw News. 

Regional Roundup Monroe Jefferson 15, Romulus Summit Academy North 12 Jefferson (11-1) repeated a 2025 playoff victory, this time edging Summit (8-4) to claim a second-straight Regional title. Ogemaw Heights 15, Negaunee 12. These two have been as evenly matched as possible the last two seasons, with Ogemaw (10-2) winning this one close after getting past Negaunee (7-5) by a point in overtime in a District opener a year ago. Grand Rapids West Catholic 45, Berrien Springs 15 The reigning champion Falcons (10-2) are one more win from a return to Ford Field after putting up 434 total yards – including 198 by running back Collin Abram – against the Shamrocks (10-2). 

11-Player Division 6

HEADLINER Kingsley 34, Sanford Meridian 28 A last-minute touchdown pushed Kingsley (12-0) past Meridian and into the Semifinals for the second straight season and third over the last four years. The Stags trailed by eight at halftime but took control from there in handing Meridian (11-1) its only defeat of the fall. Click for more from the Traverse City Record-Eagle.

Regional Roundup Detroit Edison 39, Ecorse 8 Edison (10-1) finished a season sweep of Ecorse (9-2), which suffered its only two losses of the year to the Pioneers over the last five weeks. Almont 41, Marine City 14 Almont (12-0) is an incredible combined 45-4 over the last four seasons and 10-3 in the playoffs during that run, and this win over the previously undefeated Mariners (11-1) surely will rank high on the list of highlights. Jackson Lumen Christi 56 Belding 20 The Titans (10-2) have won 23 straight playoff games going back to the start of their 2022 championship run, with this one ending Belding’s season at 9-3.

11-Player Division 7

HEADLINER Ithaca 29, Pewamo-Westphalia 10 These two met for the fourth time in the playoffs this decade and third season in a row, and Ithaca earned its first win in the series to avenge last year’s 42-21 defeat in a Regional Final. Yellowjackets quarterback Gibson Rondy starred again, throwing for three touchdowns and running for the fourth. Click for more from the Lansing State Journal.

Regional Roundup Ravenna 21, North Muskegon 14 Ravenna (10-2) clinched its first Regional championship since 2010 and made it even more memorable by avenging a 21-13 Week 8 loss to North Muskegon that had decided the West Michigan Conference Rivers title for the Norsemen (10-2). Menominee 21, Charlevoix 14 The reigning champion Maroons (11-1) held off their second-closest challenge this season on the scoreboard, but may have gotten their greatest scare as Charlevoix (8-3) led with under two minutes to play. Ottawa Lake Whiteford 32, Jonesville 20 Whiteford (10-2) ran its winning streak to double digits and claimed its second Regional title over the last four years. Jonesville ended 7-5, with its first run to the Regional Finals since 2002 despite starting this season 2-4. 

11-Player Division 8

HEADLINER New Lothrop 39, Ubly 34 New Lothrop scored the game’s final two touchdowns to claim its first Regional title since 2002 in its first single-digit game since Week 4. The Hornets (11-1) also have scored 39 or more points in eight straight games, with these 39 the most Ubly (8-4) gave up this fall. Click for more from the Flint Journal. 

Regional Roundup Hudson 61, Springport 20 By nearly the same score as their Regional Final matchup a year ago (68-22), Hudson (11-1) will move on to the Semifinals for the third time this decade and ended Springport’s run at 10-2 – but also a combined 29-6 over the last three seasons after the Spartans didn’t have a winning record from 2019-23. Madison Heights Madison 34, Clarkston Everest Collegiate 22 Madison’s second playoff win over Everest (10-2) in two seasons has the Eagles (10-2) headed to the Semifinals for the first time since 2018. Beal City 45, Bark River-Harris 16 The Aggies (12-0) have put together one of the most dominating runs in the state this fall with just one single-digit game and a combined playoff score of 141-22. The Broncos closed 9-3 with all three losses to teams that played in Regional Finals. 

MHSAA.com's weekly “1st & Goal” previews and reviews are powered by MI Student Aid, a division within the Department of Lifelong Education, Advancement, and Potential (MiLEAP). MI Student Aid encourages students to pursue postsecondary education by providing access to student financial resources and information. MI Student Aid administers the state’s scholarship and grant programs that help make college Accessible, Affordable and Attainable for you. Click to connect with MI Student Aid and find more information on Facebook and Twitter @mistudentaid.

PHOTO (Top) Ravenna celebrates its Regional championship win Saturday over North Muskegon. (Photo by Tim Reilly.)