High School a Time for Plays of All Kinds

April 2, 2015

By Jack Roberts
MHSAA executive director

At end of season or school year banquets attended by student-athletes and their parents, I often tell this short story about my mother that never fails to get a good laugh, especially from mothers:

“At the end of my junior year of high school I attended the graduation ceremony for the senior class on a hot and humid early June evening in our stuffy high school gymnasium. The bleachers on each side were filled to capacity, as were several hundred folding chairs placed on the gymnasium floor.

“The public address system, which was wonderful for announcing at basketball games or wrestling meets, was awful for graduation speeches. Person after person spoke, and the huge audience wondered what they had to say.

“I was present because I was the junior class president; and as part of the ceremony, the senior class president handed me a small shovel. It had something to do with accepting responsibility or carrying on tradition.

“In any event, the senior class president spoke briefly; and then it was my turn. I stepped to the podium, pushed the microphone to the side, and spoke in a voice that was heard and understood in every corner of the gymnasium.

“Whereupon my mother, sitting in one of the folding chairs, positioned right in front of my basketball coach – who had benched me for staying out too late on the night before a game, because I had to attend a required school play rehearsal – my mother turned around, pointed her finger at the coach and said, ‘See there? That’s what he learned at play practice!’

“And she was heard in every corner of the gymnasium too.

“But my mother knew – she just knew – that for me, play practice was as important as basketball practice. And she was absolutely correct.”

This old but true story about in-season demands of school sports actually raises two of the key issues of the debate about out-of-season coaching rules.

One is that we are not talking only about sports. School policies should not only protect and promote opportunities for students to participate in more than one sport; they should also allow for opportunities for students to participate in the non-athletic activities that comprehensive, full-service schools provide.

This is because surveys consistently link student achievement in school as well as success in later life with participation in both the athletic and non-athletic activities of schools. Proper policies permit students time to study, time to practice and play sports and time to be engaged in other school activities that provide opportunities to learn and grow as human beings.

A second issue the story presents is that parents have opinions about what is best for their children. In fact, they feel even more entitled to express those opinions today than my mother did almost 50 years ago. In fact, today, parents believe they are uniquely entitled to make the decisions that affect their children. And often they take the attitude that everyone else should butt out of their business!

The MHSAA knows from direct experience that while school administrators want tighter controls on what coaches and students do out of season, and that most student-athletes and coaches will at least tolerate the imposed limits, parents will be highly and emotionally critical of rules that interfere with how they raise their children.

No matter the cost in time or money to join elite teams, take private lessons, travel to far-away practices and further-away tournaments, no matter how unlikely any of this provides the college athletic scholarship return on investment that parents foolishly pursue, those parents believe they have every right to raise their own children their own way and that it’s not the MHSAA’s business to interfere.

It is for this very reason that MHSAA rules have little to say about what students can and can’t do out of season. Instead, the rules advise member schools and their employees what schools themselves have agreed should be the limits. The rules do this to promote competitive balance. They do this in order to avoid never-ending escalating expense of time and money to keep up on the competitive playing field, court, pool, etc.

Every example we have of organized competitive sports is that, in the absence of limits, some people push the boundaries as far as they can for their advantage, which forces other people to go beyond what they believe is right in order to keep up.

If, during the discussions on out-of-season rules, someone suggests that certain policies be eliminated, thinking people will pause to ask what life would be like without those rules.

Our outcome cannot be mere elimination of regulation, which invites chaos; the objective must be shaping a different future.

A good start would be simpler, more understandable and enforceable rules. A bad ending would be if it forces more student-athletes and school coaches to focus on a single sport year-round.

Menken Giving Back Through Coaching, Telling Story of Donor's Life-Saving Gift

By Pam Shebest
Special for MHSAA.com

November 17, 2026

KALAMAZOO — In 2017, Andrew Nicholson was a 19-year-old senior at Holly High School.

Southwest CorridorRoy Menken was a 52-year-old bowler who was dying of Alpha-1 antitrypsin deficiency, a fatal lung disease.

The two had never met, but through tragedy, the teen saved Menken’s life.

Menken, an assistant bowling coach at Kalamazoo Central, was given about six months to live when he got a call at 5:45 a.m. on May 24, 2017, from University of Michigan Health.

After waiting for 27 months, Menken was finally getting a new pair of lungs.

“Normally they give you about four hours to get to U of M,” Menken said. “In my case, Andrew’s lungs didn’t match anyone else in the U of M program, so I was the only one called.”

With his wife driving “like a mad person,” they made it to the medical center in Ann Arbor in less than two hours.

Preparing for the surgery, he said, he felt “a little scared, because you never know. Actually, I felt sad for the person who had passed. We were told that it was a young man, and he was involved in an accident.”

Andrew Nicholson, as an organ donor, provided lungs that have extended Menken’s life.

The teen was killed the day before in a welding accident.

Working in a junk yard, he was asked to weld some 55-gallon drums, which, unknown to him, still had some lacquer thinner in them.

“A week before I showed my son how to weld,” said Keith Nicholson, Andrew’s dad. “He made an eighth-inch weld and it burned through and blew up. Broke his neck, broke his forearm, broke his shoulder, broke his whole left side of his body, crushed his head.”

Fortunately for Menken, when the teen got his driver’s license at age 16, he checked the donor box.

“The day my ex-wife took him to get his driver’s license, she was standing there next to him and he said, ‘Donor, what’s that mean?’” Keith Nicholson said. “She said if you die, they can take your organs and help other people.

“Andrew shrugged his shoulders and said, ‘Well, they’re not going to do any good for me.’”

Those organs not only helped Menken, but saved four other lives, were life-changing for 12 more people (bones, etc.) and life-altering for another 33 (skin, science, etc.)

Menken sent a letter to Gift of Life Michigan through the hospital, hoping it would be forwarded to the donor’s family. The family answered, beginning a life-long friendship.

Keith Nicholson said he responded because “I was more curious making sure everything was all right. I’m really happy. I couldn’t ask for a better recipient.”

They have not only become “family,” but on the two-year anniversary of the transplant, Keith Nicholson went to Kalamazoo from Trenton to pick up the classic 1959 Impala that Menken started restoring before the surgery but could no longer finish. 

Nicholson completed work on the car and said Andrew would have done it himself if he’d had a chance.

“The only thing I ever said to Roy (about the transplant) was when we were out in the shop welding on the car, he tried to sneak out there (to help)," Nicholson recalled.

And that question was a stark reminder.

Menken, at a bowling center, is an assistant coach for Kalamazoo Central.

“I stopped welding, looked at him and said, ‘Is this what you think of my son’s gift to you?’”

Living a full life

Fueled by healthy new lungs, Menken wasted no time getting back into sports.

The transplant was in May 2017, and by that September he was playing golf. He started bowling in November.

When he walked into Continental Lanes that first day, he saw his son, Donald, who was working there.

“You could just see the emotion on his face,” Menken said. “So was (manager) Dave Fawley and my other son, Perry.

“I slowly got back into the leagues that January and haven’t quit bowling since except when COVID hit.”

Bowling at least five days a week is no problem for Menken. The hardest part, he said, is wearing a mask when he is around people, something transplant recipients are supposed to do.

The mask hasn’t interfered with his game. He’s shot a couple of 300 games since then.

Menken also competes in Transplant Games of America and World Transplant Games. Several of his 12 gold medals came from both tournaments, including a mixed doubles gold in the U.S. Games with Becky Sheets from Charlotte, who was six months out from a heart transplant.

Traveling is no problem for Menken and his wife, Jan. The World Games, held every two years, move from country to country. Last year they were in Dresden, Germany, and next year will be in Belgium.

Menken still has to travel to Ann Arbor for checkups every three months and gets weekly infusions of Prolastin (an enzyme his liver doesn’t release) at home.

Menken rolls for a spare during tournament play.

He is also in chronic rejection and relapsed twice before rebounding, which he attributes to how active he is and the 12 morning pills and 16 evening pills he takes each day.

As a teen, Menken was diagnosed with sports-induced asthma and began using inhalers. 

He said doctors never really discovered that he had Alpha-1 until one day in 2013, while he was working as a building operator for Kalamazoo County and had trouble catching his breath.

“They sent me to their doctor, and he said do you realize you are disabled?” recounted Menken, who refused to believe it.

It was not until he went to Ann Arbor for tests that he was diagnosed with end-stage lung disease and given two years to live.

He and his wife “left U of M and we were both in shock,” he said.

After returning home, he was put on two liters of oxygen and could no longer work at his job. Once he got the call for surgery, Menken said he was more afraid that something would happen to cancel the surgery than he was of dying.

The operation lasted 14 hours and when he woke the next day, he wasn’t scared but knew the operation was a success when he saw “my wife and her Aunt Marcia Godisak, who was also one of my respiratory nurses, just the looks on their faces, even though I couldn’t speak because I was still on a ventilator.”

Coaching a passion

Menken coached bowling at Portage Northern for 10 years, then started at Galesburg-Augusta until COVID-19 shut down the program. He has helped coach at Kalamazoo Central the past two years and spends time talking to clubs and schools about his journey and organ donations.

He is also in charge of the Saturday morning junior bowling leagues at Continental.

“He brings a lot of bowling knowledge that I don’t have,” K-Central head coach Krys Briggs said. “I have not had the experience, so I find people I know that are definitely more knowledgeable than I am.

Kalamazoo Central head bowling coach Krys Briggs and junior Kaeden Lutzka.

“The kids love him.”

The coach also said she passed around an article about Menken’s transplant journey for the bowlers who did not know about it.

“Personally. it makes me want to work on my health and make sure that I’m healthy just so that I don’t have to go through that,” said junior bowler Kaeden Lutzka, who heard Menken speak during one of his classes. “If I stay healthy and someone needs my organs, I can be a donor since I’m a donor on my license.”

Menken said the feeling of survivor’s guilt still haunts him.

“We honor Andrew every day,” he said.

Keith Nicholson said, “The biggest misinterpretation, and I know people say it because it’s the most common, but it’s not that we lost a son. I know where he went. I know what happened. He was just an amazing kid. He touched a lot of people’s hearts.

“Roy had less than six months to live. I’m happy for him.”

Pam Shebest

Pam Shebest served as a sportswriter at the Kalamazoo Gazette from 1985-2009 after 11 years part-time with the Gazette while teaching French and English at White Pigeon High School. She can be reached at [email protected] with story ideas for Calhoun, Kalamazoo and Van Buren counties.

PHOTOS (Top) Roy Menken’s collection of bowling awards includes several medals earned competing in national and world games for bowlers who have received organ transplants. (2) Andrew Nicholson, as an organ donor, provided lungs that have extended Menken’s life. (3) Menken, at a bowling center, is an assistant coach for Kalamazoo Central. (4) Menken rolls for a spare during tournament play. (5) Kalamazoo Central head bowling coach Krys Briggs and junior Kaeden Lutzka. (Menken, Nicholson and awards photos courtesy of Roy Menken. Headshots by Pam Shebest.)